# Batch 01 Review

## Review Metadata

- Batch ID: `2026-05-17-batch-01`
- Case ID: `case-formal-proof-search-001`
- Arm ID: `full_ofone`
- Run ID: `2026-05-17-batch-01__case-formal-proof-search-001__full_ofone__agentic_coding__r2`
- Reviewer: local Codex unblinded review
- Review date: 2026-05-18
- Blinding status: `unblinded`

## Pre-Score Compliance Gate

| Check | Result | Notes |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Case fidelity | `pass` | Artifact identity and artifact-level benchmark trace bind to `case-formal-proof-search-001`, repeat 2, the full-OfOne prompt, and the expected input-bundle hash. |
| Required outputs present | `pass` | Raw Markdown output, artifact JSON, validator JSON, rendering, patch report, and review file are present. |
| Independence from other arms/examples | `pass` | The artifact is case-native for the formal proof-search repeat-2 slot and does not reuse another case artifact or another benchmark arm output. |
| No-superiority compliance | `pass` | The output does not claim empirical superiority. |
| Auto-reject before aggregate scoring | `no` | No pre-score gate row failed. |

## Semantic Fidelity

- Case binding: Pass; the response addresses the incomplete proof path, candidate lemma, countermodel pressure, unknowns, and update triggers.
- Copied-example risk: Low; the response is scoped to the formal proof-search case and repeat-2 run metadata.
- Evidence provenance adequacy: Frozen case-file evidence is scenario-level but stable, hash-bound, and explicit about missing formal artifacts.
- Artifact/source identity: Artifact, run ID, case ID, prompt hash, input-bundle hash, validator, rendering, patch report, and review file align with the repeat-2 run record.

## Scores

| Metric | Score | Rationale |
| --- | ---: | --- |
| decision_quality | 4 | Correctly keeps theorem state unresolved and separates proof, lemma, countermodel, and timeout paths. |
| evidence_grounding_precision | 4 | Uses stable evidence hashes and separates formal claims from missing proof evidence. |
| uncertainty_calibration | 4 | Blocks proof conclusion on certificate/countermodel and lemma unknowns. |
| trace_completeness | 4 | Links evidence, claims, unknowns, criteria, edges, loops, options, triggers, and rendering. |
| auditability | 4 | Includes case-native artifact, benchmark trace, validator JSON, rendering, patch report, and review file. |
| update_quality | 4 | Patch/scoped-rerun behavior reaches proof claims, options, tradeoff surface, and rendering. |
| cost | 2 | Full artifact and machine-output burden is much heavier than text arms. |
| inter_run_stability | NA | Repeat-2 is present, but aggregate stability scoring is deferred. |

## Required Notes

- Strongest decision-relevant contribution: It makes proof certificate absence, lemma obligation, countermodel pressure, timeout risk, triggers, and rendering dependency inspectable as decision state.
- Most important unsupported claim or missing evidence: The case lacks actual axioms, theorem statement, inference rules, checker output, proof certificate, lemma proof, and countermodel artifact.
- Hidden variable or unknown that changed the review: Candidate lemma status and formalization integrity determine whether the proof path can survive.
- Gate, safety, or release concern: Do not accept proved/not-entailed status without the appropriate formal certificate or countermodel evidence.
- Patch/update behavior, if applicable: Trigger `T1` propagates countermodel/lemma evidence through claims, options, tradeoff surface, and rendering; `T2` remains available for scoped rerun when formalization changes.
- Failure mode observed: No case-binding failure; remaining limitation is that the benchmark dossier remains abstract and lacks real formal artifacts.

## Adjudication

- Accept run for aggregate scoring: `yes`
- If no, reason: N/A
- Reviewer confidence: `medium`