# Batch 01 Review

## Review Metadata

- Batch ID: `2026-05-17-batch-01`
- Case ID: `case-strategic-gated-diligence-001`
- Arm ID: `full_ofone`
- Run ID: `2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1`
- Reviewer: local Codex unblinded review
- Review date: 2026-05-20
- Blinding status: `unblinded`

## Pre-Score Compliance Gate

| Check | Result | Notes |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Case fidelity | `pass` | The artifact identity, raw output metadata, and artifact-level benchmark trace target `case-strategic-gated-diligence-001` and the expected full-OfOne run ID. |
| Required outputs present | `fail` | The raw output includes artifact JSON, validator narrative, rendering, and patch narrative, but the computed local validator fails semantic graph checks and contradicts the artifact self-attestation. |
| Independence from other arms/examples | `pass` | No copied-example artifact identity or other-arm dependency is visible; the failure is local semantic validity, not wrong-case reuse. |
| No-superiority compliance | `pass` | The artifact keeps `superiority_ready=false` and makes no empirical superiority claim. |
| Auto-reject before aggregate scoring | `yes` | Full-OfOne outputs must pass executable local validation before aggregate eligibility; this run is excluded before metric aggregation. |

## Semantic Fidelity

- Case binding: Pass; `artifact_identity.case_id`, `benchmark_trace.case_id`, and `benchmark_trace.run_id` bind to the intended strategic gated diligence frontier run.
- Copied-example risk: Low; content is case-native and does not carry the earlier wrong-case identity failure.
- Evidence provenance adequacy: Adequate for a scenario-level benchmark case, with hashes for the case file, full-OfOne prompt, skill protocol, and validation model; operational facts remain intentionally abstract.
- Artifact/source identity: Raw Markdown output, downloaded source, artifact JSON, validator JSON, rendering, patch report, and review file all identify the same run and case.

## Scores

| Metric | Score | Rationale |
| --- | ---: | --- |
| decision_quality | 4 | The recommendation correctly approves bounded diligence while blocking operational launch behind unresolved unknowns and an open release gate. |
| evidence_grounding_precision | 4 | The artifact separates case-file evidence, protocol evidence, validation-model evidence, and claims with explicit content hashes. |
| uncertainty_calibration | 4 | Launch-critical evidence and reviewer ownership remain open blockers with medium overall confidence. |
| trace_completeness | 2 | The artifact is richly structured, but the executable validator found an illegal relation and missing option-effect edge references. |
| auditability | 2 | The run is highly inspectable through raw, artifact, validator, rendering, and patch files, but validator failure blocks benchmark-valid audit status. |
| update_quality | 2 | Patch machinery runs, but trigger/edge defects mean update closure cannot be accepted as a valid benchmark artifact. |
| cost | 2 | The full-OfOne Deep Research run carries materially higher collection and review cost than text-only arms. |
| inter_run_stability | NA | This is the first reviewed frontier-reasoning repeat for the full-OfOne strategic slot. |

## Required Notes

- Strongest decision-relevant contribution: It repairs the earlier wrong-case identity failure by producing a case-native artifact with benchmark trace binding.
- Most important unsupported claim or missing evidence: The artifact self-attests validator pass even though the computed local validator fails relation legality and option expected-effect reference checks.
- Hidden variable or unknown that changed the review: `U1` and `U2` correctly block launch, but their edge/option propagation is not valid enough for aggregate scoring.
- Gate, safety, or release concern: Gate `G1` remains open; operational launch remains blocked.
- Patch/update behavior, if applicable: Trigger `T1` can be processed by the patch script, but the invalid graph prevents accepting the closure as benchmark-valid.
- Failure mode observed: Frontier full-OfOne output can be case-bound and prose-plausible while still failing executable semantic validation.

## Adjudication

- Accept run for aggregate scoring: `no`
- If no, reason: Computed local validation failed semantic graph checks: edge `X3` uses an illegal token-to-claim `constrains` relation, option `O1` is missing expected-effect edges `U1` and `U2`, option `O2` is missing expected-effect edge `R1`, and artifact self-attestation conflicts with the computed validator result.
- Reviewer confidence: `high`

## Local Validator Adjudication

- Source: `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/outputs/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1.validator.json`
- Decision: `reject before aggregate scoring`
- Key rule learned: case-bound is not validator-valid.
- Remediation: launch a remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun or repair the protocol prompt so future full-OfOne artifacts satisfy executable semantic validation before aggregate eligibility.