{
  "ofone_version": "0.6.0",
  "mode": "Map",
  "charter": {
    "objective": "Decide how to handle a plausible scientific mechanism with limited measurements, possible confounding, and a proposed intervention.",
    "scope": [
      "scientific mechanism check",
      "measurement validation",
      "confounder review",
      "intervention gating"
    ],
    "horizon": "one validation cycle before relying on the intervention",
    "stakes": [
      "mechanism validity",
      "intervention misfire risk",
      "measurement quality"
    ],
    "risk_tier": "medium",
    "movement_jobs": [
      "BOUND",
      "TEST",
      "GATE"
    ]
  },
  "artifact_identity": {
    "artifact_id": "OFONE-2026-05-18-B01-SCI-FULL-R3",
    "case_id": "case-scientific-mechanism-check-001",
    "objective_head": "scientific mechanism check before intervention",
    "scope_hash": "sha256:cdb33da5247bb175b9655bd1fd8e402eb32cd3a82506aceb8dfb5de13caa62c8",
    "config_hash": "sha256:3729b6ba39d84329c6fb569aa0ca170ff52ae991fea83d6f40a3fde4b18053c1",
    "active_evidence_hashes": [
      "sha256:1e8a179003b68c1e158877b688e56d3845a2d4ac9056e69d10eefb64835241d3",
      "sha256:8234aa01407d60791bfc31bca2dcf5a8dcee355c18a156cc5bc6b3273dbe45e4"
    ],
    "created_at": "2026-05-18T09:52:00Z",
    "status": "draft",
    "movement_jobs": [
      "BOUND",
      "TRIGGER"
    ]
  },
  "adapter_projection": {
    "primary": "scientific-explanatory",
    "axes": {
      "scientific-explanatory": [
        "measurement quality",
        "mechanism claim",
        "confounder risk",
        "contradictory-observation update"
      ]
    },
    "movement_jobs": [
      "BOUND",
      "LINK"
    ]
  },
  "scene": {
    "scene_id": "S1",
    "frames": [
      {
        "frame_id": "F1",
        "type": "causal",
        "assumptions": [
          "The proposed mechanism should be represented as a causal hypothesis, not as established fact."
        ]
      },
      {
        "frame_id": "F2",
        "type": "evidential",
        "assumptions": [
          "Limited measurements and possible confounding reduce the strength of any intervention recommendation."
        ]
      },
      {
        "frame_id": "F3",
        "type": "temporal",
        "assumptions": [
          "New contradictory measurement should trigger a patch before the intervention is relied on."
        ]
      }
    ],
    "tokens": [
      {
        "token_id": "K1",
        "kind": "entity",
        "label": "research team"
      },
      {
        "token_id": "K2",
        "kind": "variable",
        "label": "observed measurement pattern"
      },
      {
        "token_id": "K3",
        "kind": "claim",
        "label": "plausible mechanism hypothesis"
      },
      {
        "token_id": "K4",
        "kind": "uncertainty",
        "label": "possible confounder"
      },
      {
        "token_id": "K5",
        "kind": "option",
        "label": "proposed intervention"
      },
      {
        "token_id": "K6",
        "kind": "gate",
        "label": "validation gate before intervention reliance"
      },
      {
        "token_id": "K7",
        "kind": "trigger",
        "label": "contradictory new measurement"
      }
    ],
    "state_variables": [
      "measurement quality",
      "mechanism support",
      "confounder status",
      "intervention readiness"
    ],
    "observed_variables": [
      "plausible mechanism",
      "limited measurements",
      "possible confounding",
      "proposed intervention"
    ],
    "hidden_variables": [
      "measurement error",
      "selection bias",
      "unobserved confounder",
      "regime shift"
    ],
    "movement_jobs": [
      "BOUND",
      "WARN",
      "TEST"
    ],
    "subscenes": [
      {
        "subscene_id": "SS1",
        "parent_scene": "S1",
        "purpose": "evidence_acquisition",
        "frames": [
          "F2"
        ],
        "tokens": [
          "K2",
          "K4"
        ],
        "entry_conditions": [
          "current measurements are limited"
        ],
        "exit_conditions": [
          "measurement protocol and confounder screen are specified"
        ],
        "movement_jobs": [
          "GROUND",
          "TEST"
        ]
      },
      {
        "subscene_id": "SS2",
        "parent_scene": "S1",
        "purpose": "causal_mechanism",
        "frames": [
          "F1"
        ],
        "tokens": [
          "K3",
          "K5"
        ],
        "entry_conditions": [
          "mechanism is plausible but not established"
        ],
        "exit_conditions": [
          "mechanism survives measurement and confounder checks or is revised"
        ],
        "movement_jobs": [
          "CLAIM",
          "TEST"
        ]
      },
      {
        "subscene_id": "SS3",
        "parent_scene": "S1",
        "purpose": "review_gate",
        "frames": [
          "F3"
        ],
        "tokens": [
          "K6",
          "K7"
        ],
        "entry_conditions": [
          "team wants to rely on the intervention"
        ],
        "exit_conditions": [
          "validation reviewer approves, blocks, or requests replication"
        ],
        "movement_jobs": [
          "GATE",
          "TRIGGER"
        ]
      }
    ]
  },
  "evidence": [
    {
      "evidence_id": "E1",
      "source": "file",
      "span_or_locator": "benchmarks/cases/scientific-mechanism-check.md#Prompt",
      "provenance": "frozen benchmark case dossier",
      "recency": "current",
      "reliability": "medium",
      "permission": "public",
      "content_hash": "sha256:1e8a179003b68c1e158877b688e56d3845a2d4ac9056e69d10eefb64835241d3",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-05-18T09:52:00Z",
      "extract": "Case dossier states there is a plausible mechanism, limited measurements, possible confounding, and a proposed intervention.",
      "source_owner": "OfOne benchmark suite",
      "chain_of_custody": "Read from frozen local benchmark case during full_ofone scientific repeat-3 run construction.",
      "supports": [
        "C1",
        "C2",
        "C3"
      ],
      "risks": [
        "scenario_level_only",
        "no_external_measurement_data"
      ],
      "movement_jobs": [
        "GROUND",
        "BOUND"
      ]
    },
    {
      "evidence_id": "E2",
      "source": "file",
      "span_or_locator": "benchmarks/cases/scientific-mechanism-check.md#Expected-OfOne-Pressure-Points",
      "provenance": "frozen benchmark case dossier",
      "recency": "current",
      "reliability": "medium",
      "permission": "public",
      "content_hash": "sha256:8234aa01407d60791bfc31bca2dcf5a8dcee355c18a156cc5bc6b3273dbe45e4",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-05-18T09:52:00Z",
      "extract": "Expected pressure points include measurement versus mechanism separation, confounder and hidden-variable visibility, testability, evidence validity windows, and update behavior when new measurement contradicts the mechanism.",
      "source_owner": "OfOne benchmark suite",
      "chain_of_custody": "Read from frozen local benchmark case during full_ofone scientific repeat-3 run construction.",
      "supports": [
        "C4",
        "C5"
      ],
      "risks": [
        "pressure_points_are_requirements_not_empirical_findings"
      ],
      "movement_jobs": [
        "GROUND",
        "WARN"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "claims": [
    {
      "claim_id": "C1",
      "text": "The proposed mechanism remains a hypothesis because the case gives limited measurements rather than mechanism-isolating evidence.",
      "type": "descriptive",
      "supports": [
        "E1"
      ],
      "contradicts": [],
      "depends_on": [],
      "confidence": {
        "level": "high",
        "basis": [
          "provenance",
          "adapter_fit"
        ],
        "failure_modes": [
          "case dossier is abstract"
        ]
      },
      "status": "active",
      "review_gate": false,
      "movement_jobs": [
        "CLAIM",
        "BOUND"
      ]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "C2",
      "text": "Possible confounding creates hidden-variable risk for the mechanism claim.",
      "type": "causal",
      "supports": [
        "E1"
      ],
      "contradicts": [],
      "depends_on": [
        "C1"
      ],
      "confidence": {
        "level": "medium",
        "basis": [
          "hidden_variable_risk",
          "mechanism_fit"
        ],
        "failure_modes": [
          "confounder is acknowledged but not named"
        ]
      },
      "status": "active",
      "review_gate": false,
      "movement_jobs": [
        "CLAIM",
        "WARN"
      ]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "C3",
      "text": "The intervention should stay behind a validation gate until measurement adequacy and confounder pressure are resolved.",
      "type": "operational",
      "supports": [
        "E1"
      ],
      "contradicts": [],
      "depends_on": [
        "C1",
        "C2"
      ],
      "confidence": {
        "level": "medium",
        "basis": [
          "mechanism_fit",
          "hidden_variable_risk",
          "adapter_fit"
        ],
        "failure_modes": [
          "validation threshold not specified"
        ]
      },
      "status": "active",
      "review_gate": true,
      "movement_jobs": [
        "CLAIM",
        "GATE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "C4",
      "text": "A contradictory new measurement should patch the mechanism claim and the intervention recommendation.",
      "type": "operational",
      "supports": [
        "E2"
      ],
      "contradicts": [],
      "depends_on": [
        "C1",
        "C2",
        "C3"
      ],
      "confidence": {
        "level": "high",
        "basis": [
          "provenance",
          "adapter_fit"
        ],
        "failure_modes": [
          "new measurement may be noisy"
        ]
      },
      "status": "active",
      "review_gate": false,
      "movement_jobs": [
        "CLAIM",
        "TRIGGER"
      ]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "C5",
      "text": "The highest-value next move is a falsifiable validation cycle that specifies measurement protocol, confounder tests, and kill conditions.",
      "type": "operational",
      "supports": [
        "E2"
      ],
      "contradicts": [],
      "depends_on": [
        "C1",
        "C2",
        "C3"
      ],
      "confidence": {
        "level": "medium",
        "basis": [
          "mechanism_fit",
          "hidden_variable_risk"
        ],
        "failure_modes": [
          "measurement protocol cost unknown"
        ]
      },
      "status": "active",
      "review_gate": false,
      "movement_jobs": [
        "CLAIM",
        "MOVE",
        "TEST"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "unknowns": [
    {
      "unknown_id": "U1",
      "kind": "missing_measurement",
      "description": "The case does not specify the measurement protocol, instrument quality, sample context, or replication evidence.",
      "blocks": [
        "R1",
        "O2"
      ],
      "resolution_move": "Define and run a measurement protocol or replication check before intervention reliance.",
      "status": "open",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "WARN",
        "TEST",
        "GATE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "unknown_id": "U2",
      "kind": "unobserved_variable",
      "description": "The possible confounder is acknowledged but unnamed and untested.",
      "blocks": [
        "O2"
      ],
      "resolution_move": "Identify likely confounders and test whether they explain the observed measurement pattern.",
      "status": "open",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "WARN",
        "TEST"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "kill_tests": [
    {
      "test_id": "KT1",
      "target": "C2",
      "test_type": "measurement",
      "condition": "measurement invalidation: new measurements fail to show the predicted pattern when likely confounders are controlled",
      "falsifies": [
        "C2",
        "C3",
        "O2"
      ],
      "movement_jobs": [
        "TEST",
        "WARN"
      ]
    },
    {
      "test_id": "KT2",
      "target": "C3",
      "test_type": "replication",
      "condition": "failed replication: the mechanism does not replicate under the planned measurement protocol",
      "falsifies": [
        "C3",
        "O2"
      ],
      "movement_jobs": [
        "TEST",
        "GATE"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "actors": [
    {
      "actor_id": "A1",
      "label": "research team",
      "role": "operator",
      "incentives": [
        "resolve mechanism uncertainty",
        "avoid acting on confounded evidence"
      ],
      "exposures": [
        "measurement error",
        "intervention misfire"
      ],
      "authority": "advise",
      "legitimacy_basis": "owns measurement design and mechanism review",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "BOUND",
        "TEST"
      ]
    },
    {
      "actor_id": "A2",
      "label": "validation reviewer",
      "role": "reviewer",
      "incentives": [
        "block premature intervention reliance",
        "require testable mechanism support"
      ],
      "exposures": [
        "false causal inference",
        "avoidable intervention cost"
      ],
      "authority": "block",
      "legitimacy_basis": "reviews whether mechanism evidence is adequate before action",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "GATE",
        "WARN"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "criteria": [
    {
      "criterion_id": "CR1",
      "name": "Measurement adequacy",
      "kind": "threshold",
      "priority": "must",
      "threshold": "Mechanism support requires a specified measurement protocol and interpretable observations.",
      "owned_by": [
        "A1",
        "A2"
      ],
      "movement_jobs": [
        "EVALUATE",
        "TEST"
      ]
    },
    {
      "criterion_id": "CR2",
      "name": "Confounder pressure addressed",
      "kind": "threshold",
      "priority": "must",
      "threshold": "The intervention cannot be relied on while a plausible untested confounder could explain the observed pattern.",
      "owned_by": [
        "A2"
      ],
      "movement_jobs": [
        "EVALUATE",
        "GATE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "criterion_id": "CR3",
      "name": "Patchability under contradiction",
      "kind": "objective",
      "priority": "should",
      "threshold": "Contradictory measurements should trigger a scoped revision of the mechanism and intervention recommendation.",
      "owned_by": [
        "A1"
      ],
      "movement_jobs": [
        "TRIGGER",
        "EVALUATE"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "edges": [
    {
      "edge_id": "X1",
      "from": "E1",
      "to": "C1",
      "relation_family": "evidential",
      "relation": "supports",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E1"
      ],
      "confidence": "high",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "LINK",
        "GROUND"
      ]
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "X2",
      "from": "E1",
      "to": "C2",
      "relation_family": "evidential",
      "relation": "supports",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E1"
      ],
      "confidence": "medium",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "LINK",
        "WARN"
      ]
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "X3",
      "from": "C2",
      "to": "C3",
      "relation_family": "argumentative",
      "relation": "supports",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E1"
      ],
      "confidence": "medium",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "LINK",
        "GATE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "X4",
      "from": "U1",
      "to": "R1",
      "relation_family": "workflow_state",
      "relation": "blocks",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E1"
      ],
      "confidence": "high",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "WARN",
        "GATE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "X5",
      "from": "U2",
      "to": "O2",
      "relation_family": "workflow_state",
      "relation": "blocks",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E1"
      ],
      "confidence": "high",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "WARN",
        "GATE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "X6",
      "from": "T1",
      "to": "C2",
      "relation_family": "workflow_state",
      "relation": "updates",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E2"
      ],
      "confidence": "medium",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "TRIGGER",
        "LINK"
      ]
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "X7",
      "from": "CR2",
      "to": "O2",
      "relation_family": "causal",
      "relation": "constrains",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "E2"
      ],
      "confidence": "high",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "EVALUATE",
        "GATE"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "loops": [
    {
      "loop_id": "L1",
      "type": "measurement",
      "edges": [
        "X1",
        "X2",
        "X6"
      ],
      "polarity": "balancing",
      "delay": "medium",
      "gain": "medium",
      "control_points": [
        "CR1",
        "T1"
      ],
      "observable_cues": [
        "new measurement contradicts mechanism",
        "replication fails or supports predicted pattern"
      ],
      "failure_mode": "limited measurements are over-read as mechanism proof",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "TEST",
        "TRIGGER",
        "WARN"
      ]
    },
    {
      "loop_id": "L2",
      "type": "contradiction",
      "edges": [
        "X4",
        "X5",
        "X6"
      ],
      "polarity": "mixed",
      "delay": "unknown",
      "gain": "high",
      "control_points": [
        "G1",
        "KT1"
      ],
      "observable_cues": [
        "confounder explains observation",
        "intervention effect does not match mechanism"
      ],
      "failure_mode": "contradictory measurement is treated as noise without review",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "WARN",
        "GATE",
        "TEST"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "option_moves": [
    {
      "option_id": "O1",
      "move_type": "test",
      "preconditions": [
        "C1",
        "C5"
      ],
      "expected_effects": [
        "X1",
        "X2",
        "X6"
      ],
      "tradeoffs": [
        "adds validation effort",
        "reduces mechanism and intervention risk"
      ],
      "blocking_unknowns": [],
      "review_gate": "G1",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "MOVE",
        "TEST"
      ]
    },
    {
      "option_id": "O2",
      "move_type": "act",
      "preconditions": [
        "C3"
      ],
      "expected_effects": [
        "X5",
        "X7"
      ],
      "tradeoffs": [
        "faster intervention",
        "higher risk of acting on confounded mechanism"
      ],
      "blocking_unknowns": [
        "U1",
        "U2"
      ],
      "review_gate": "G1",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "MOVE",
        "GATE",
        "WARN"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "tradeoff_surface": {
    "surface_id": "TS1",
    "options": [
      "O1",
      "O2"
    ],
    "criteria": [
      "CR1",
      "CR2",
      "CR3"
    ],
    "dominant_option": "O1",
    "why": [
      "CR1",
      "CR2",
      "CR3"
    ],
    "reversal_conditions": [
      "U1",
      "U2",
      "T1"
    ],
    "movement_jobs": [
      "EVALUATE",
      "TRIGGER"
    ]
  },
  "temporal_model": {
    "time_horizon": "one validation cycle before intervention reliance",
    "decision_deadline": "unknown",
    "evidence_validity_windows": [
      {
        "evidence_id": "E1",
        "valid_until": "until benchmark case dossier changes",
        "staleness_trigger": "case dossier changes or supplies new measurement data"
      },
      {
        "evidence_id": "E2",
        "valid_until": "until benchmark pressure points change",
        "staleness_trigger": "case adds or removes contradiction/update requirement"
      }
    ],
    "update_cadence": "patch immediately when contradictory measurement evidence arrives",
    "movement_jobs": [
      "BOUND",
      "TRIGGER"
    ]
  },
  "information_value": [
    {
      "unknown_id": "U1",
      "decision_impact": "high",
      "resolution_cost": "medium",
      "time_to_resolve": "one measurement-design and replication cycle",
      "risk_reduction": "high",
      "recommended_next_query": "What measurement protocol and observed result would support or contradict the mechanism?",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "TEST",
        "MOVE",
        "EVALUATE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "unknown_id": "U2",
      "decision_impact": "high",
      "resolution_cost": "medium",
      "time_to_resolve": "one confounder-screen cycle",
      "risk_reduction": "high",
      "recommended_next_query": "Which hidden variable or confounder could explain the observed pattern without the proposed mechanism?",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "TEST",
        "WARN",
        "EVALUATE"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "lenses": [
    {
      "lens_id": "LENS1",
      "name": "measurement adequacy",
      "adapter_axis": "scientific-explanatory",
      "questions": [
        "Are the observations sufficient to support the mechanism?",
        "What measurement would contradict it?"
      ],
      "claims_examined": [
        "C1",
        "C4",
        "C5"
      ],
      "blind_spots": [
        "no actual sample, instrument, or control details in the case dossier"
      ],
      "contention": [
        "limited measurement should not be treated as mechanism proof"
      ],
      "movement_jobs": [
        "TEST",
        "WARN",
        "EVALUATE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "lens_id": "LENS2",
      "name": "confounder pressure",
      "adapter_axis": "scientific-explanatory",
      "questions": [
        "Could a hidden variable explain the observed pattern?",
        "Does intervention reliance remain blocked?"
      ],
      "claims_examined": [
        "C2",
        "C3"
      ],
      "blind_spots": [
        "confounder is possible but unnamed"
      ],
      "contention": [
        "intervention should remain gated while U2 is open"
      ],
      "movement_jobs": [
        "WARN",
        "GATE",
        "TEST"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "council_result": {
    "coverage": [
      "scientific-explanatory"
    ],
    "missing_lenses": [
      "domain-specific measurement specialist"
    ],
    "major_dissent": [
      "Do not rely on the intervention until measurements and confounders are tested."
    ],
    "decision_effect": "run measurement/confounder validation first and keep intervention gated",
    "movement_jobs": [
      "EVALUATE",
      "WARN",
      "GATE"
    ]
  },
  "triggers": [
    {
      "trigger_id": "T1",
      "condition": "new_evidence",
      "affected_objects": [
        "E2",
        "C2",
        "C3",
        "C4",
        "U1",
        "U2",
        "G1",
        "O1",
        "O2",
        "TS1"
      ],
      "transition": "patch",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "TRIGGER",
        "TEST"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "gates": [
    {
      "gate_id": "G1",
      "condition": "Intervention reliance requires validation reviewer approval after measurement adequacy and confounder pressure are addressed.",
      "reviewer": "A2",
      "required_decision": "approve intervention reliance, block it, or require replication/confounder testing",
      "status": "open",
      "movement_jobs": [
        "GATE",
        "WARN"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "confidence_model": {
    "overall": "medium",
    "provenance_strength": "medium",
    "source_independence": "low",
    "recency": "high",
    "mechanism_fit": "medium",
    "contradiction_load": "low",
    "hidden_variable_risk": "high",
    "adversarial_risk": "low",
    "adapter_fit": "high",
    "movement_jobs": [
      "EVALUATE",
      "WARN"
    ]
  },
  "decision_rendering": {
    "rendering_id": "R1",
    "summary": "Treat the mechanism as provisional; rely on the intervention only after measurement quality and confounder checks pass.",
    "recommendation": "Run a falsifiable validation cycle and keep intervention reliance gated.",
    "confidence": "medium",
    "depends_on": [
      "C1",
      "C2",
      "C3",
      "C5",
      "U1",
      "O1",
      "TS1",
      "G1",
      "L1",
      "COUNCIL"
    ],
    "movement_jobs": [
      "EVALUATE",
      "MOVE",
      "GATE"
    ]
  },
  "review_log": [],
  "benchmark_trace": {
    "trace_id": "BT-2026-05-17-B01-SCI-FULL-R3",
    "suite_id": "ofone-v0.5-three-arm-evaluation",
    "cases_run": 1,
    "arms_run": [
      "full_ofone"
    ],
    "model_families": 1,
    "superiority_ready": false,
    "diagnostics": [
      "single repeat-3 benchmark run only",
      "no empirical superiority claim supported",
      "Batch 01 remains below release minimums"
    ],
    "case_id": "case-scientific-mechanism-check-001",
    "run_id": "2026-05-17-batch-01__case-scientific-mechanism-check-001__full_ofone__agentic_coding__r3",
    "case_file": "benchmarks/cases/scientific-mechanism-check.md",
    "case_file_sha256": "sha256:1126bb9ba5d97df4a9e82070d16df5ae4ffa61226d3d98a91b6c121671bb8efc",
    "prompt_file": "benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/prompts/full_ofone.md",
    "prompt_file_sha256": "sha256:613afac8909b34accb57fd2c24217bb59a28a45860e32f36f6ec5f7f4ab5587e",
    "input_bundle_sha256": "sha256:5bae3d6429075001dc0feff579bd382810c9419b50bc4c5055272477bdc77b6d",
    "movement_jobs": [
      "BOUND",
      "WARN",
      "TRIGGER"
    ]
  }
}