{ "ofone_version": "0.6.0", "mode": "Map", "charter": { "objective": "Decide whether to authorize a reversible diligence move before operational launch.", "scope": [ "bounded diligence authorization", "launch release gate", "known versus assumed facts", "blocking unknowns", "update logic" ], "horizon": "short diligence cycle before launch commitment", "stakes": [ "operational launch control", "compliance exposure", "reputation exposure", "resource commitment" ], "risk_tier": "medium", "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "GATE" ] }, "artifact_identity": { "artifact_id": "OFONE-B01-STRAT-R3", "case_id": "case-strategic-gated-diligence-001", "objective_head": "strategic gated diligence repeat 3", "scope_hash": "sha256:2c3e1169096b586534cccc7f26ee1ae8c79ed3740e7a94758cf8a60476163e33", "config_hash": "sha256:7baced060b9fe66a921cadd0699f0a33d971c211cb49f78d9e04db6fb0da178f", "active_evidence_hashes": [ "sha256:3be79a868090a3224139855a47f88bb7ddc3251d9c43b2fe3d312b4ef6681647", "sha256:a039512f9bfed8a80d18e2ed76ef7f141e38d0ec48ad5246d61799b5c506b951" ], "created_at": "2026-05-18T03:35:25-06:00", "status": "review_pending", "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "TRIGGER" ] }, "adapter_projection": { "primary": "hybrid", "axes": { "strategic-agentic": [ "bounded reversible move", "launch sequencing", "owner authority" ], "normative-evaluative": [ "gate legitimacy", "stakeholder exposure", "reputation control" ] }, "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "EVALUATE" ] }, "scene": { "scene_id": "S1", "frames": [ { "frame_id": "F1", "type": "strategic", "assumptions": [ "Diligence can be separated from launch if commitments stay bounded." ] }, { "frame_id": "F2", "type": "normative", "assumptions": [ "Launch legitimacy requires explicit review authority before exposure is created." ] }, { "frame_id": "F3", "type": "temporal", "assumptions": [ "The decision is staged: diligence now, launch only after update and gate review." ] } ], "tokens": [ { "token_id": "TOK1", "kind": "option", "label": "bounded diligence move" }, { "token_id": "TOK2", "kind": "option", "label": "operational launch" }, { "token_id": "TOK3", "kind": "gate", "label": "release approval gate" }, { "token_id": "TOK4", "kind": "unknown", "label": "missing diligence evidence package" }, { "token_id": "TOK5", "kind": "trigger", "label": "new release evidence" } ], "subscenes": [ { "subscene_id": "SS1", "parent_scene": "S1", "purpose": "evidence_acquisition", "frames": [ "F1" ], "tokens": [ "TOK1", "TOK4" ], "entry_conditions": [ "team can investigate without launch commitment" ], "exit_conditions": [ "evidence package is complete or a blocker is found" ], "movement_jobs": [ "GROUND", "TEST" ] }, { "subscene_id": "SS2", "parent_scene": "S1", "purpose": "option_decision", "frames": [ "F1", "F3" ], "tokens": [ "TOK1", "TOK2" ], "entry_conditions": [ "diligence findings are available" ], "exit_conditions": [ "choose diligence, launch, or defer" ], "movement_jobs": [ "MOVE", "EVALUATE" ] }, { "subscene_id": "SS3", "parent_scene": "S1", "purpose": "review_gate", "frames": [ "F2" ], "tokens": [ "TOK3" ], "entry_conditions": [ "launch transition is requested" ], "exit_conditions": [ "reviewer approves, blocks, or returns for evidence" ], "movement_jobs": [ "GATE", "WARN" ] } ], "state_variables": [ "diligence scope", "launch commitment state", "gate status", "evidence completeness" ], "observed_variables": [ "case states reversible diligence before launch", "case requires gate and update logic" ], "hidden_variables": [ "actual reviewer authority", "irreversibility threshold", "stakeholder interpretation of diligence", "cost and reputational exposure" ], "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "LINK" ] }, "evidence": [ { "evidence_id": "E1", "source": "file", "span_or_locator": "benchmarks/cases/strategic-gated-diligence.md#Prompt", "provenance": "benchmark case dossier", "recency": "current", "reliability": "medium", "permission": "public", "content_hash": "sha256:3be79a868090a3224139855a47f88bb7ddc3251d9c43b2fe3d312b4ef6681647", "retrieved_at": "2026-05-18T03:35:25-06:00", "extract": "A team is considering a reversible diligence move before committing to an operational launch.", "source_owner": "CryptoJym/ofone-skillchain benchmark case", "chain_of_custody": "Read from local repository during Batch 01 repeat-3 generation; bound by benchmark_trace case_file_sha256.", "supports": [ "C1", "C2" ], "risks": [ "scenario-level evidence only" ], "movement_jobs": [ "GROUND" ] }, { "evidence_id": "E2", "source": "file", "span_or_locator": "benchmarks/cases/strategic-gated-diligence.md#Expected OfOne Pressure Points", "provenance": "benchmark case dossier", "recency": "current", "reliability": "medium", "permission": "public", "content_hash": "sha256:a039512f9bfed8a80d18e2ed76ef7f141e38d0ec48ad5246d61799b5c506b951", "retrieved_at": "2026-05-18T03:35:25-06:00", "extract": "The answer must distinguish known, assumed, blocked, gate-controlled, and update-changing elements.", "source_owner": "CryptoJym/ofone-skillchain benchmark case", "chain_of_custody": "Read from local repository during Batch 01 repeat-3 generation; bound by benchmark_trace case_file_sha256.", "supports": [ "C2", "C3", "C4" ], "risks": [ "pressure points do not provide concrete launch evidence" ], "movement_jobs": [ "GROUND", "WARN" ] } ], "claims": [ { "claim_id": "C1", "text": "A bounded diligence authorization is supportable only if the move remains inquiry-only, reversible, and visibly separate from operational launch.", "type": "operational", "supports": [ "E1" ], "contradicts": [], "depends_on": [ "E1" ], "confidence": { "level": "medium", "basis": [ "provenance", "adapter_fit", "hidden_variable_risk" ], "failure_modes": [ "diligence may create irreversible commitments" ] }, "status": "active", "review_gate": false, "movement_jobs": [ "CLAIM", "MOVE" ] }, { "claim_id": "C2", "text": "Operational launch remains blocked until release criteria, reviewer authority, and approval evidence are all present.", "type": "operational", "supports": [ "E1", "E2" ], "contradicts": [], "depends_on": [ "E1", "E2", "G1" ], "confidence": { "level": "high", "basis": [ "provenance", "adapter_fit", "contradiction_load" ], "failure_modes": [ "review authority is not specified in the case" ] }, "status": "active", "review_gate": true, "movement_jobs": [ "CLAIM", "GATE" ] }, { "claim_id": "C3", "text": "The map must keep known facts, assumptions, blockers, gate authority, and update triggers separately addressable.", "type": "normative", "supports": [ "E2" ], "contradicts": [], "depends_on": [ "E2" ], "confidence": { "level": "high", "basis": [ "provenance", "adapter_fit" ], "failure_modes": [ "over-compression could hide blockers" ] }, "status": "active", "review_gate": false, "movement_jobs": [ "CLAIM", "LINK" ] }, { "claim_id": "C4", "text": "A named release authority is required before launch can move from blocked to approved.", "type": "operational", "supports": [ "E2" ], "contradicts": [], "depends_on": [ "E2", "A2" ], "confidence": { "level": "medium", "basis": [ "provenance", "hidden_variable_risk", "adapter_fit" ], "failure_modes": [ "actor is role-defined but not personally named" ] }, "status": "active", "review_gate": true, "movement_jobs": [ "CLAIM", "GATE" ] } ], "unknowns": [ { "unknown_id": "U1", "kind": "missing_evidence", "description": "The repeat-3 map still lacks a concrete diligence evidence package, launch threshold, and pass/fail criteria.", "blocks": [ "O2", "R1" ], "resolution_move": "Define the diligence checklist, launch criteria, and evidence owner before requesting launch approval.", "status": "open", "movement_jobs": [ "WARN", "TEST", "GATE" ] }, { "unknown_id": "U2", "kind": "unobserved_variable", "description": "The release reviewer is role-defined but not named, and the exact authority boundary is absent.", "blocks": [ "G1", "R1" ], "resolution_move": "Assign the release reviewer and document approval authority before the gate can close.", "status": "open", "movement_jobs": [ "WARN", "GATE" ] } ], "kill_tests": [ { "test_id": "KT1", "target": "C1", "test_type": "constraint_violation", "condition": "Gate escalation: diligence creates irreversible launch exposure, public commitment, or material spend before approval.", "falsifies": [ "C1" ], "movement_jobs": [ "TEST", "WARN" ] }, { "test_id": "KT2", "target": "C2", "test_type": "stakeholder_objection", "condition": "Adapter conflict or stakeholder objection shows the proposed reviewer lacks legitimate authority over launch release.", "falsifies": [ "C2", "C4" ], "movement_jobs": [ "TEST", "GATE" ] } ], "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "CR1", "name": "Reversibility preserved", "kind": "constraint", "priority": "must", "threshold": "Diligence cannot create irreversible operational, financial, compliance, or reputation exposure.", "owned_by": [ "A1" ], "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "GATE" ] }, { "criterion_id": "CR2", "name": "Release authority explicit", "kind": "threshold", "priority": "must", "threshold": "Operational launch requires named release reviewer approval.", "owned_by": [ "A2" ], "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "GATE" ] }, { "criterion_id": "CR3", "name": "Assumption and blocker visibility", "kind": "objective", "priority": "should", "threshold": "Knowns, assumptions, unknowns, and update triggers stay visible in the decision rendering.", "owned_by": [ "A1" ], "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "WARN" ] } ], "tradeoff_surface": { "surface_id": "TS1", "options": [ "O1", "O2", "O3" ], "criteria": [ "CR1", "CR2", "CR3" ], "dominant_option": "O1", "why": [ "CR1", "CR2", "CR3" ], "reversal_conditions": [ "U1", "T1" ], "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "TRIGGER" ] }, "actors": [ { "actor_id": "A1", "label": "team decision owner", "role": "decision_owner", "incentives": [ "learn enough to decide without premature commitment" ], "exposures": [ "resource commitment", "reputation" ], "authority": "approve", "legitimacy_basis": "owns the diligence authorization decision", "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "MOVE" ] }, { "actor_id": "A2", "label": "release reviewer", "role": "reviewer", "incentives": [ "avoid unapproved launch exposure" ], "exposures": [ "compliance", "reputation" ], "authority": "block", "legitimacy_basis": "controls operational launch release gate", "movement_jobs": [ "GATE", "WARN" ] }, { "actor_id": "A3", "label": "affected operators and stakeholders", "role": "affected_party", "incentives": [ "avoid surprise launch obligations" ], "exposures": [ "operational workload", "trust" ], "authority": "observe", "legitimacy_basis": "would bear downstream execution or reputation effects", "movement_jobs": [ "WARN" ] } ], "temporal_model": { "time_horizon": "one bounded diligence cycle before launch", "decision_deadline": "unknown", "evidence_validity_windows": [ { "evidence_id": "E1", "valid_until": "until case dossier changes", "staleness_trigger": "case prompt changes or a concrete source bundle supersedes it" }, { "evidence_id": "E2", "valid_until": "until case dossier changes", "staleness_trigger": "pressure points change or benchmark prompt is revised" } ], "update_cadence": "patch map when new diligence evidence or gate decision appears", "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "TRIGGER", "WARN" ] }, "information_value": [ { "unknown_id": "U1", "decision_impact": "high", "resolution_cost": "medium", "time_to_resolve": "one diligence planning cycle", "risk_reduction": "high", "recommended_next_query": "What specific evidence checklist, threshold, and owner would convert the diligence cycle into a launch/no-launch decision?", "movement_jobs": [ "TEST", "MOVE", "EVALUATE" ] }, { "unknown_id": "U2", "decision_impact": "high", "resolution_cost": "low", "time_to_resolve": "before launch gate review", "risk_reduction": "medium", "recommended_next_query": "Who is the named release authority, what can they approve or block, and where is that decision recorded?", "movement_jobs": [ "GATE", "MOVE", "EVALUATE" ] } ], "lenses": [ { "lens_id": "LENS1", "name": "strategic sequencing", "adapter_axis": "strategic-agentic", "questions": [ "Can the team learn without committing?", "Which move preserves reversibility?" ], "claims_examined": [ "C1", "C2" ], "blind_spots": [ "actual cost threshold", "counterparty expectations" ], "contention": [ "diligence may be interpreted as launch if boundaries are not written" ], "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "WARN" ] }, { "lens_id": "LENS2", "name": "release legitimacy", "adapter_axis": "normative-evaluative", "questions": [ "Who can approve exposure?", "Who bears the risk if launch is implied?" ], "claims_examined": [ "C2", "C3", "C4" ], "blind_spots": [ "named reviewer absent" ], "contention": [ "role-defined approval is weaker than named authority" ], "movement_jobs": [ "GATE", "WARN" ] } ], "council_result": { "coverage": [ "strategic-agentic", "normative-evaluative" ], "missing_lenses": [ "legal-specific counsel if real compliance obligations exist" ], "major_dissent": [ "launch must remain blocked because release evidence and reviewer identity are missing" ], "decision_effect": "approve bounded diligence as an inquiry move only; keep launch blocked until evidence and named authority close the release gate", "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "WARN", "GATE" ] }, "edges": [ { "edge_id": "EDGE1", "from": "E1", "to": "C1", "relation_family": "evidential", "relation": "supports", "evidence_refs": [ "E1" ], "confidence": "medium", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "GROUND" ] }, { "edge_id": "EDGE2", "from": "E1", "to": "C2", "relation_family": "evidential", "relation": "supports", "evidence_refs": [ "E1" ], "confidence": "medium", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "GROUND" ] }, { "edge_id": "EDGE3", "from": "E2", "to": "C3", "relation_family": "evidential", "relation": "supports", "evidence_refs": [ "E2" ], "confidence": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "GROUND" ] }, { "edge_id": "EDGE4", "from": "C2", "to": "O2", "relation_family": "causal", "relation": "constrains", "evidence_refs": [ "E1", "E2" ], "confidence": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "GATE" ] }, { "edge_id": "EDGE5", "from": "C1", "to": "O1", "relation_family": "causal", "relation": "enables", "evidence_refs": [ "E1" ], "confidence": "medium", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "MOVE" ] }, { "edge_id": "EDGE6", "from": "U1", "to": "O2", "relation_family": "workflow_state", "relation": "blocks", "evidence_refs": [], "confidence": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "WARN", "GATE" ] }, { "edge_id": "EDGE7", "from": "G1", "to": "O2", "relation_family": "workflow_state", "relation": "blocks", "evidence_refs": [], "confidence": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "GATE", "LINK" ] }, { "edge_id": "EDGE8", "from": "CR1", "to": "O1", "relation_family": "argumentative", "relation": "evaluates", "evidence_refs": [ "E1" ], "confidence": "medium", "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "LINK" ] }, { "edge_id": "EDGE9", "from": "TS1", "to": "R1", "relation_family": "argumentative", "relation": "supports", "evidence_refs": [], "confidence": "medium", "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "MOVE" ] }, { "edge_id": "EDGE10", "from": "T1", "to": "R1", "relation_family": "workflow_state", "relation": "updates", "evidence_refs": [], "confidence": "medium", "movement_jobs": [ "TRIGGER", "LINK" ] } ], "loops": [ { "loop_id": "LOOP1", "type": "review", "edges": [ "EDGE7" ], "polarity": "balancing", "delay": "medium", "gain": "medium", "control_points": [ "G1", "A2" ], "observable_cues": [ "gate status is open or approved", "reviewer decision record exists" ], "failure_mode": "Gate becomes symbolic and launch proceeds without approval.", "movement_jobs": [ "GATE", "WARN" ] }, { "loop_id": "LOOP2", "type": "learning", "edges": [ "EDGE6", "EDGE10" ], "polarity": "mixed", "delay": "short", "gain": "medium", "control_points": [ "U1", "T1" ], "observable_cues": [ "new diligence evidence changes blocker status", "rendering recommendation changes" ], "failure_mode": "New evidence arrives but does not patch the rendered recommendation.", "movement_jobs": [ "TRIGGER", "TEST" ] } ], "option_moves": [ { "option_id": "O1", "move_type": "query", "preconditions": [ "C1", "C3" ], "expected_effects": [ "EDGE5", "EDGE8" ], "tradeoffs": [ "low commitment but slower than direct launch", "preserves reversibility while collecting decision evidence" ], "blocking_unknowns": [], "review_gate": "none", "movement_jobs": [ "MOVE", "TEST" ] }, { "option_id": "O2", "move_type": "act", "preconditions": [ "C2", "C4" ], "expected_effects": [ "EDGE4", "EDGE7" ], "tradeoffs": [ "faster if approved but unacceptable while evidence and reviewer are missing" ], "blocking_unknowns": [ "U1", "U2" ], "review_gate": "G1", "movement_jobs": [ "MOVE", "GATE", "WARN" ] }, { "option_id": "O3", "move_type": "defer", "preconditions": [ "C2" ], "expected_effects": [ "EDGE4" ], "tradeoffs": [ "avoids exposure but fails to learn what diligence could safely reveal" ], "blocking_unknowns": [ "U1" ], "review_gate": "none", "movement_jobs": [ "MOVE", "WARN" ] } ], "triggers": [ { "trigger_id": "T1", "condition": "new_evidence", "affected_objects": [ "E1", "U1" ], "transition": "patch", "movement_jobs": [ "TRIGGER", "GROUND" ] }, { "trigger_id": "T2", "condition": "review_required", "affected_objects": [ "G1" ], "transition": "human_review", "movement_jobs": [ "TRIGGER", "GATE" ] } ], "gates": [ { "gate_id": "G1", "condition": "Compliance/reputation release gate: operational launch cannot proceed until diligence evidence and reviewer authority are complete.", "reviewer": "A2 release reviewer", "required_decision": "approve, block, or return launch request for more evidence", "status": "open", "movement_jobs": [ "GATE", "WARN" ] } ], "confidence_model": { "overall": "medium", "provenance_strength": "medium", "source_independence": "low", "recency": "high", "mechanism_fit": "medium", "contradiction_load": "low", "hidden_variable_risk": "high", "adversarial_risk": "medium", "adapter_fit": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "WARN" ] }, "decision_rendering": { "rendering_id": "R1", "summary": "Authorize inquiry-only diligence; keep launch blocked by missing evidence, named authority, and an open release gate.", "recommendation": "Proceed with bounded diligence under written guardrails. Do not launch, externally commit, or spend irreversibly until the evidence package is complete and G1 is approved by the named release authority.", "confidence": "medium", "depends_on": [ "C1", "C2", "C3", "C4", "U1", "U2", "O1", "O2", "TS1", "G1", "T1", "T2", "TEMPORAL", "COUNCIL" ], "movement_jobs": [ "MOVE", "EVALUATE", "GATE" ] }, "benchmark_trace": { "trace_id": "BT-STRAT-R3", "suite_id": "ofone-v0.5-three-arm-evaluation", "cases_run": 5, "arms_run": [ "direct_answer", "light_structured", "full_ofone" ], "model_families": 1, "superiority_ready": false, "diagnostics": [ "Batch 01 is still in progress; repeat 3 supports local pre-score compliance only, not a superiority claim." ], "case_id": "case-strategic-gated-diligence-001", "run_id": "2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__full_ofone__agentic_coding__r3", "case_file": "benchmarks/cases/strategic-gated-diligence.md", "case_file_sha256": "sha256:18a0247003e142c80c8748eb4652f900b81ca409b91ba7c370e1362d24680942", "prompt_file": "benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/prompts/full_ofone.md", "prompt_file_sha256": "sha256:613afac8909b34accb57fd2c24217bb59a28a45860e32f36f6ec5f7f4ab5587e", "input_bundle_sha256": "sha256:4168a4e6533f1398611d704254b48c8fbfde5f547a4a0c79cd072a98fdbacd44", "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "GROUND", "TRIGGER" ] } }