{ "ofone_version": "0.6.0", "mode": "Map", "charter": { "objective": "Choose the next move before operational launch so the team preserves reversibility, makes gate ownership explicit, and knows what evidence would change the recommendation.", "scope": [ "Distinguish reversible diligence from operational launch", "Make reviewer ownership and release gating explicit", "Record the current unknown that blocks launch and can patch the recommendation", "Represent the trigger that changes the recommendation when new evidence arrives" ], "horizon": "Immediate pre-launch decision window", "stakes": [ "Premature launch can collapse reversibility", "Launch without explicit approval weakens governance legitimacy", "Incomplete diligence can force avoidable remediation later" ], "risk_tier": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "MOVE", "GATE", "WARN" ] }, "artifact_identity": { "artifact_id": "OFONE-case-strategic-gated-diligence-001-rerun2", "case_id": "case-strategic-gated-diligence-001", "objective_head": "reversible diligence before launch", "scope_hash": "sha256:56037e1f0d77eac194ff1614d04922ea298bba9722587a4ff8d462fa8bd12afc", "config_hash": "sha256:4dfec02e2d80d0f48e5f8db5f6e116880ea88078e60f34dcd665091aad274b7c", "active_evidence_hashes": [ "sha256:3be79a868090a3224139855a47f88bb7ddc3251d9c43b2fe3d312b4ef6681647", "sha256:f2effc968969b3208d4cef5fb0c787eb07d0c6174db85a5d8652b7bacffc696b", "sha256:755fcfbb9c725b5f64ff6c652b5068db39f01d31bc7ee34f2fe5f0f72a909a6d" ], "created_at": "2026-05-21T00:00:00Z", "status": "review_pending", "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "GROUND", "TRIGGER" ] }, "adapter_projection": { "primary": "hybrid", "axes": { "strategic-agentic": [ "favor reversible moves under uncertainty", "treat launch as separate from diligence", "preserve the option to narrow, defer, or approve later" ], "normative-evaluative": [ "require explicit approval before launch", "make reviewer ownership legible", "treat open gate status as release-blocking" ] }, "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "LINK", "GATE" ] }, "scene": { "scene_id": "S1", "frames": [ { "frame_id": "F1", "type": "strategic", "assumptions": [ "Reversibility has positive value while evidence is incomplete", "Diligence can be scoped separately from operational launch" ] }, { "frame_id": "F2", "type": "normative", "assumptions": [ "Operational launch requires a legitimate approval step", "Open gate status is not equivalent to tacit approval" ] }, { "frame_id": "F3", "type": "temporal", "assumptions": [ "The decision is explicitly pre-launch", "A later update may patch the recommendation without rewriting the whole map" ] } ], "tokens": [], "subscenes": [ { "subscene_id": "SS1", "parent_scene": "S1", "purpose": "option_decision", "frames": [ "F1", "F3" ], "tokens": [], "entry_conditions": [ "Operational launch has not yet been committed" ], "exit_conditions": [ "A next move is selected as diligence-first or launch-now" ], "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "MOVE" ] }, { "subscene_id": "SS2", "parent_scene": "S1", "purpose": "review_gate", "frames": [ "F2", "F3" ], "tokens": [], "entry_conditions": [ "Operational launch is under consideration" ], "exit_conditions": [ "Gate G1 is approved, blocked, or returned for more diligence" ], "movement_jobs": [ "GATE", "WARN" ] } ], "state_variables": [ "launch_commitment_state", "gate_status_G1", "unknown_status_U1" ], "observed_variables": [ "The case separates reversible diligence from operational launch", "The case requires gate status and reviewer ownership to be explicit" ], "hidden_variables": [ "The exact diligence package", "The exact reviewer identity beyond a required approval role", "The threshold that would make launch acceptable after diligence" ], "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "WARN" ] }, "evidence": [ { "evidence_id": "E1", "source": "file", "span_or_locator": "Pasted text(13).txt L84-L85", "provenance": "Authoritative benchmark case statement supplied in the conversation", "recency": "current", "reliability": "high", "permission": "restricted", "content_hash": "sha256:3be79a868090a3224139855a47f88bb7ddc3251d9c43b2fe3d312b4ef6681647", "retrieved_at": "2026-05-21 conversation attachment", "extract": "A team is considering a reversible diligence move before committing to an operational launch.", "source_owner": "benchmark operator via user-supplied case file", "chain_of_custody": "Uploaded or pasted into the current conversation and treated as authoritative and complete.", "supports": [ "C1", "C4" ], "risks": [ "case does not specify diligence contents", "single-source case description" ] }, { "evidence_id": "E2", "source": "file", "span_or_locator": "Pasted text(13).txt L91-L97", "provenance": "Authoritative benchmark pressure-point block supplied in the conversation", "recency": "current", "reliability": "high", "permission": "restricted", "content_hash": "sha256:f2effc968969b3208d4cef5fb0c787eb07d0c6174db85a5d8652b7bacffc696b", "retrieved_at": "2026-05-21 conversation attachment", "extract": "Expected pressure points: distinction between diligence and launch; actor/reviewer ownership; gate status and required approval; rendering-blocking unknowns; patch closure from new evidence to the rendered recommendation.", "source_owner": "benchmark operator via user-supplied case file", "chain_of_custody": "Uploaded or pasted into the current conversation and treated as authoritative and complete.", "supports": [ "C2", "C3", "C6" ], "risks": [ "pressure points do not define numeric thresholds", "reviewer identity is not named" ] }, { "evidence_id": "E3", "source": "file", "span_or_locator": "Pasted text(13).txt L57-L63", "provenance": "Authoritative benchmark constraints supplied in the conversation", "recency": "current", "reliability": "high", "permission": "restricted", "content_hash": "sha256:755fcfbb9c725b5f64ff6c652b5068db39f01d31bc7ee34f2fe5f0f72a909a6d", "retrieved_at": "2026-05-21 conversation attachment", "extract": "Include source identity and explicit unknowns when evidence is missing or provisional. Do not treat the rendered recommendation as the internal map.", "source_owner": "benchmark operator via user-supplied case file", "chain_of_custody": "Uploaded or pasted into the current conversation and treated as authoritative and complete.", "supports": [ "C2", "C5" ], "risks": [ "case still leaves implementation detail open" ] } ], "claims": [ { "claim_id": "C1", "text": "Reversible diligence and operational launch are distinct choices in this case and should not be collapsed into one move.", "type": "descriptive", "supports": [ "E1", "E2" ], "contradicts": [], "depends_on": [], "confidence": { "level": "high", "basis": [ "provenance", "adapter_fit" ], "failure_modes": [ "case text could omit domain-specific edge cases" ] }, "status": "active", "review_gate": false, "movement_jobs": [ "CLAIM", "LINK" ] }, { "claim_id": "C2", "text": "Operational launch should remain gated until a reviewer records an explicit decision on completed diligence.", "type": "normative", "supports": [ "E2", "E3" ], "contradicts": [], "depends_on": [ "G1" ], "confidence": { "level": "high", "basis": [ "provenance", "adapter_fit" ], "failure_modes": [ "review role could be narrower or broader than assumed" ] }, "status": "active", "review_gate": true, "movement_jobs": [ "CLAIM", "GATE", "WARN" ] }, { "claim_id": "C3", "text": "Launching before diligence resolves the main blocking unknown increases irreversible commitment risk and weakens review discipline.", "type": "predictive", "supports": [ "E2" ], "contradicts": [], "depends_on": [ "U1", "G1" ], "confidence": { "level": "medium", "basis": [ "hidden_variable_risk", "adapter_fit", "mechanism_fit" ], "failure_modes": [ "diligence could be trivial in some unstated contexts", "launch could be partly reversible" ] }, "status": "active", "review_gate": true, "movement_jobs": [ "CLAIM", "WARN", "GATE" ] }, { "claim_id": "C4", "text": "A bounded diligence move can be started now without committing the team to operational launch.", "type": "operational", "supports": [ "E1" ], "contradicts": [], "depends_on": [], "confidence": { "level": "medium", "basis": [ "provenance", "mechanism_fit" ], "failure_modes": [ "the diligence design could secretly commit irreversible spend or public release behavior" ] }, "status": "active", "review_gate": false, "movement_jobs": [ "CLAIM", "MOVE" ] }, { "claim_id": "C5", "text": "If diligence resolves U1 and the same evidence supports an approve outcome at G1, the recommendation can be patched from diligence-first to launch-eligible.", "type": "predictive", "supports": [ "E2", "E3" ], "contradicts": [], "depends_on": [ "U1", "G1" ], "confidence": { "level": "medium", "basis": [ "adapter_fit", "mechanism_fit" ], "failure_modes": [ "resolved diligence may still fail approval", "new evidence may introduce additional blockers" ] }, "status": "active", "review_gate": true, "movement_jobs": [ "CLAIM", "TRIGGER", "GATE" ] }, { "claim_id": "C6", "text": "Immediate launch reduces reversibility because it converts a learn-first decision into an operational commitment under uncertainty.", "type": "predictive", "supports": [ "E2" ], "contradicts": [], "depends_on": [ "O2" ], "confidence": { "level": "medium", "basis": [ "hidden_variable_risk", "mechanism_fit", "adapter_fit" ], "failure_modes": [ "some launch implementations could remain partially reversible" ] }, "status": "active", "review_gate": true, "movement_jobs": [ "CLAIM", "WARN", "MOVE" ] } ], "unknowns": [ { "unknown_id": "U1", "kind": "missing_evidence", "description": "No completed diligence artifact currently states whether launch satisfies reviewer criteria without losing reversibility.", "blocks": [ "O2", "R1" ], "resolution_move": "Run bounded diligence and submit the result to gate G1 for an explicit approval decision.", "status": "open", "movement_jobs": [ "WARN", "GATE", "TEST" ] } ], "kill_tests": [ { "test_id": "KT1", "target": "C4", "test_type": "constraint_violation", "condition": "If the proposed diligence step irreversibly commits launch resources or public release behavior, the claim that diligence is reversible is false.", "falsifies": [ "C4" ], "movement_jobs": [ "TEST", "WARN" ] } ], "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "CR1", "name": "No launch without explicit approval", "kind": "constraint", "priority": "must", "threshold": "Operational launch is not acceptable until gate G1 records an explicit approve decision.", "owned_by": [ "A2" ], "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "GATE" ] }, { "criterion_id": "CR2", "name": "Prefer reversibility under uncertainty", "kind": "preference", "priority": "should", "threshold": "When material uncertainty is open, prefer a move that preserves the option to narrow, defer, or approve later.", "owned_by": [ "A1" ], "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "MOVE" ] }, { "criterion_id": "CR3", "name": "Use the smallest move that changes the decision", "kind": "objective", "priority": "should", "threshold": "The next move should create the evidence needed for a gate decision without merging diligence into launch.", "owned_by": [ "A1", "A2" ], "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "TEST" ] } ], "tradeoff_surface": { "surface_id": "TS1", "options": [ "O1", "O2" ], "criteria": [ "CR1", "CR2", "CR3" ], "dominant_option": "O1", "why": [ "CR1", "CR2", "CR3" ], "reversal_conditions": [ "U1", "G1", "T1" ], "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "TRIGGER" ] }, "actors": [ { "actor_id": "A1", "label": "team decision owner", "role": "decision_owner", "incentives": [ "preserve optionality", "learn before committing launch" ], "exposures": [ "delay cost", "accountability for a premature operational launch" ], "authority": "approve", "legitimacy_basis": "Owns the sequencing decision between diligence and launch.", "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "MOVE", "GATE" ] }, { "actor_id": "A2", "label": "release reviewer", "role": "reviewer", "incentives": [ "enforce explicit approval before launch", "ensure the gate is evidence-backed" ], "exposures": [ "missed blocker risk", "legitimacy loss if launch is tacitly approved" ], "authority": "block", "legitimacy_basis": "Holds the required approval role for moving from diligence to launch.", "movement_jobs": [ "GATE", "WARN" ] } ], "information_value": [ { "unknown_id": "U1", "decision_impact": "high", "resolution_cost": "medium", "time_to_resolve": "one bounded diligence cycle", "risk_reduction": "high", "recommended_next_query": "What bounded diligence deliverable would let A2 approve, block, or return the launch request without committing to launch today?", "movement_jobs": [ "TEST", "MOVE", "EVALUATE" ] } ], "lenses": [ { "lens_id": "LENS1", "name": "reversibility and option value", "adapter_axis": "strategic-agentic", "questions": [ "Does the next move preserve optionality while uncertainty is still material?" ], "claims_examined": [ "C1", "C3", "C4", "C6" ], "blind_spots": [ "exact diligence package is not named in the case" ], "contention": [ "Immediate launch consumes optionality before U1 is resolved" ], "movement_jobs": [ "WARN", "TEST", "EVALUATE" ] }, { "lens_id": "LENS2", "name": "approval legitimacy and release gating", "adapter_axis": "normative-evaluative", "questions": [ "What explicit approval is required before launch and what evidence would make it legitimate?" ], "claims_examined": [ "C2", "C3", "C5" ], "blind_spots": [ "named reviewer identity is not supplied in the case" ], "contention": [ "Open gate status is release-blocking, not a soft signal to proceed" ], "movement_jobs": [ "WARN", "GATE", "EVALUATE" ] } ], "council_result": { "coverage": [ "strategic-agentic", "normative-evaluative" ], "missing_lenses": [], "major_dissent": [], "decision_effect": "Both lenses favor reversible diligence now and block launch pending resolved evidence plus an explicit gate decision.", "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "WARN", "GATE" ] }, "temporal_model": { "time_horizon": "Immediate pre-launch sequencing decision", "decision_deadline": "before any operational launch commitment", "evidence_validity_windows": [ { "evidence_id": "E1", "valid_until": "until the case statement changes", "staleness_trigger": "case scope or launch state changes" }, { "evidence_id": "E2", "valid_until": "until pressure points change", "staleness_trigger": "new reviewer rule, new launch threshold, or new diligence output appears" }, { "evidence_id": "E3", "valid_until": "until benchmark constraints change", "staleness_trigger": "prompt contract or validation constraints change" } ], "update_cadence": "patch immediately when new diligence evidence or a gate decision arrives", "movement_jobs": [ "BOUND", "TRIGGER", "WARN" ] }, "edges": [ { "edge_id": "X1", "from": "E1", "to": "C1", "relation_family": "evidential", "relation": "supports", "evidence_refs": [ "E1" ], "confidence": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "GROUND" ] }, { "edge_id": "X2", "from": "E2", "to": "C2", "relation_family": "evidential", "relation": "supports", "evidence_refs": [ "E2" ], "confidence": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "GROUND" ] }, { "edge_id": "X3", "from": "E2", "to": "C3", "relation_family": "evidential", "relation": "supports", "evidence_refs": [ "E2" ], "confidence": "medium", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "GROUND" ] }, { "edge_id": "X4", "from": "U1", "to": "O2", "relation_family": "workflow_state", "relation": "blocks", "evidence_refs": [], "confidence": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "WARN" ] }, { "edge_id": "X5", "from": "G1", "to": "O2", "relation_family": "workflow_state", "relation": "blocks", "evidence_refs": [], "confidence": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "GATE", "WARN" ] }, { "edge_id": "X6", "from": "C2", "to": "O2", "relation_family": "workflow_state", "relation": "blocks", "evidence_refs": [ "E2", "E3" ], "confidence": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "GATE" ] }, { "edge_id": "X7", "from": "CR1", "to": "O2", "relation_family": "argumentative", "relation": "evaluates", "evidence_refs": [], "confidence": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "EVALUATE" ] }, { "edge_id": "X8", "from": "C4", "to": "C5", "relation_family": "causal", "relation": "enables", "evidence_refs": [ "E1", "E3" ], "confidence": "medium", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "MOVE", "TRIGGER" ] }, { "edge_id": "X9", "from": "C3", "to": "C6", "relation_family": "causal", "relation": "causes", "evidence_refs": [ "E2" ], "confidence": "medium", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "WARN" ] }, { "edge_id": "X10", "from": "CR2", "to": "O1", "relation_family": "argumentative", "relation": "evaluates", "evidence_refs": [], "confidence": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "EVALUATE" ] }, { "edge_id": "X11", "from": "CR3", "to": "O1", "relation_family": "argumentative", "relation": "evaluates", "evidence_refs": [], "confidence": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "EVALUATE" ] }, { "edge_id": "X12", "from": "E3", "to": "C5", "relation_family": "evidential", "relation": "supports", "evidence_refs": [ "E3" ], "confidence": "medium", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "GROUND" ] } ], "loops": [ { "loop_id": "L1", "type": "review", "edges": [ "X4", "X8", "X5" ], "polarity": "balancing", "delay": "medium", "gain": "medium", "control_points": [ "scope the diligence package", "record a gate G1 decision" ], "observable_cues": [ "U1 is reduced by diligence output", "G1 changes from open to approved, blocked, or returned_for_evidence" ], "failure_mode": "The team informally treats diligence as launch and bypasses the explicit approval gate.", "movement_jobs": [ "LINK", "WARN", "GATE" ] } ], "option_moves": [ { "option_id": "O1", "move_type": "test", "preconditions": [ "C1", "C4" ], "expected_effects": [ "X8" ], "tradeoffs": [ "delays launch", "creates evidence for G1", "preserves reversibility" ], "blocking_unknowns": [], "review_gate": "none", "movement_jobs": [ "MOVE", "TEST", "EVALUATE" ] }, { "option_id": "O2", "move_type": "act", "preconditions": [ "C1" ], "expected_effects": [ "X9" ], "tradeoffs": [ "speeds execution", "consumes reversibility", "adds gate and review exposure" ], "blocking_unknowns": [ "U1" ], "review_gate": "G1", "movement_jobs": [ "MOVE", "GATE", "WARN" ] } ], "triggers": [ { "trigger_id": "T1", "condition": "new_evidence", "affected_objects": [ "U1", "G1" ], "transition": "patch", "movement_jobs": [ "TRIGGER", "WARN" ] }, { "trigger_id": "T2", "condition": "review_required", "affected_objects": [ "C2", "O2" ], "transition": "human_review", "movement_jobs": [ "TRIGGER", "GATE" ] } ], "gates": [ { "gate_id": "G1", "condition": "Any proposed transition from diligence to operational launch", "reviewer": "A1 decision owner and A2 release reviewer must record an explicit decision", "required_decision": "approve launch, block launch, or return for more diligence", "status": "open", "movement_jobs": [ "GATE" ] } ], "confidence_model": { "overall": "medium", "provenance_strength": "high", "source_independence": "low", "recency": "high", "mechanism_fit": "medium", "contradiction_load": "low", "hidden_variable_risk": "high", "adversarial_risk": "low", "adapter_fit": "high", "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "WARN" ] }, "decision_rendering": { "rendering_id": "R1", "summary": "Run bounded reversible diligence now; do not authorize operational launch while U1 is open and gate G1 remains unapproved.", "recommendation": "Choose O1 now. Treat O2 as blocked until diligence resolves U1 and gate G1 records an explicit approve decision.", "confidence": "medium", "depends_on": [ "C1", "C2", "C3", "C4", "C5", "U1", "O1", "TS1", "G1", "TEMPORAL", "COUNCIL" ], "movement_jobs": [ "EVALUATE", "MOVE", "GATE", "WARN" ] }, "benchmark_trace": { "trace_id": "BT-case-strategic-gated-diligence-001-rerun2", "suite_id": "2026-05-17-batch-01", "cases_run": 1, "arms_run": [ "full_ofone" ], "model_families": 1, "superiority_ready": false, "diagnostics": [ "Case-bound remedial rerun for a single full-OfOne slot; not evidence of superiority.", "Trace binds the artifact to the frozen case, prompt, and input bundle hashes." ], "case_id": "case-strategic-gated-diligence-001", "run_id": "2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1__rerun2", "case_file": "benchmarks/cases/strategic-gated-diligence.md", "case_file_sha256": "sha256:18a0247003e142c80c8748eb4652f900b81ca409b91ba7c370e1362d24680942", "prompt_file": "benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/prompts/full_ofone.md", "prompt_file_sha256": "sha256:613afac8909b34accb57fd2c24217bb59a28a45860e32f36f6ec5f7f4ab5587e", "input_bundle_sha256": "sha256:4168a4e6533f1398611d704254b48c8fbfde5f547a4a0c79cd072a98fdbacd44", "movement_jobs": [ "GROUND", "WARN", "TRIGGER" ] } }