# Run 07 Status Ledger

Run: OfOne Post-Run06 Benchmark Hardening Review
Run ID: 07
Lifecycle state: integrated
Conversation URL: https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0a6259-357c-83e8-b67a-6db72e4af30a
Prompt: `research/prompts/2026-05-17-07-ofone-post-run06-hardening-review.md`
Context: `research/ofone-post-run06-hardening-context.md`
Baseline implementation commit under review: `579b14902c401611309322fdd89e1d136c8bae05`
Packet publication commit: `e1d14c6`
Latest public protocol commit before launch: `7ed31908f86397097441bc10079340c8be8eed42`

## Prepared Scope

This run asks GPT 5.5 Pro / ChatGPT Deep Research to review the public repository after Run 06 remediation. It should audit whether benchmark-case binding, pre-score auto-reject, immutable validator/patch artifacts, semantic-fidelity fields, matrix state semantics, and excluded-run logging are sufficient before the next Batch 01 benchmark slice.

## Prepared Verification

- 2026-05-17T18:40:37-06:00: Local repo clean at baseline implementation commit `579b14902c401611309322fdd89e1d136c8bae05`.
- 2026-05-17T18:40:37-06:00: `npm run research:check` passed.
- 2026-05-17T18:40:37-06:00: `npm run benchmark` passed.
- 2026-05-17T18:40:37-06:00: `npm run pages:check` passed against GitHub Pages.
- 2026-05-17T18:44:23-06:00: Packet wiring prepared locally; `npm run schema:check`, `npm run validate`, `npm run review:check`, `npm run research:check`, `npm run benchmark`, and `npm test` passed. Pages parity is intentionally held until the packet is committed, pushed, and published.
- 2026-05-17T18:45:00-06:00: Packet committed and pushed to `main` as `e1d14c6`.
- 2026-05-17T18:47:22-06:00: Prompt updated with the `chatgpt-deep-research-pro` research protocol block before launch.
- 2026-05-17T18:50:56-06:00: Latest public protocol commit before launch was `7ed31908f86397097441bc10079340c8be8eed42`.

## Launch Rule

This run is not launched until ChatGPT Deep Research has a generated plan, `Start` is clicked, and the UI shows active research with stop-control evidence. After launch, update this ledger, the tracker, and any relevant public status fields before harvest.

## Launch Proof

- 2026-05-17T18:50:56-06:00: Opened a clean ChatGPT root conversation and launched Run 07 at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0a6259-357c-83e8-b67a-6db72e4af30a.
- Observed model/mode before launch: expanded model selector showed `Latest • 5.5`; selected option showed `Pro • Extended`; composer showed `Pro` after Deep Research was enabled.
- Deep Research was enabled before submit; the composer showed `Deep research, click to remove`.
- Context handoff: combined prompt/context was delivered as a pasted document labeled `Pasted markdown.md`; the visible user message instructed ChatGPT to use the attached pasted text as the full Deep Research request and context.
- Generated plan title: `OfOne Run07 hardening review`.
- Start action: clicked `Start` on the Deep Research plan card.
- Active proof: card shows `Researching...`; `Stop research` button is visible.

## Status Updates

- 2026-05-17T18:53:48-06:00: Run 07 remains active in ChatGPT Deep Research. Visible status text changed to `Opening execution matrix lines...`; step 1 (`Collect Run06 benchmark results and related artifacts from provided sources`) is active; `Stop research` remains present. Report is not ready to harvest.
- 2026-05-17T18:55:52-06:00: Run 07 remains active. Visible progress: step 1 complete, step 2 active (`Analyze Run06 failures and performance regressions against benchmarks`), status text `Inspecting case file and benchmark for artifact mismatch...`, visible count `11 searches`, and `Stop research` remains present. Report is not ready to harvest.
- 2026-05-17T19:13:57-06:00: Run 07 remains active after extended polling. Visible progress is still step 1 complete and step 2 active; status text is now `Reviewing Run07 and available pages...`; visible count remains `11 searches`; `Stop research` remains present. Treat as a possible active-run stall, but do not stop or relaunch while ChatGPT still shows active research.
- 2026-05-17T19:20:42-06:00: Run 07 remains active and appears to have resumed movement after the possible stall. Visible progress remains step 1 complete and step 2 active; status text changed to `Confirming state of main and baseline artifacts...`; visible count remains `11 searches`; `Stop research` remains present. Report is not ready to harvest.
- 2026-05-17T19:24:35-06:00: Run 07 remains active in ChatGPT Deep Research. Visible progress remains step 1 complete and step 2 active; status text changed to `Identifying the rerun gap in current process...`; visible count remains `11 searches`; `Stop research` remains present. This is material to the standing recursive-improvement loop, so it is recorded without harvesting or relaunching.
- 2026-05-17T19:40:08-06:00: Run 07 remains active and unchanged past the 15-minute watchdog threshold. Visible progress remains step 1 complete and step 2 active; status text remains `Identifying the rerun gap in current process...`; visible count remains `11 searches`; `Stop research` remains present. Treat as a possible active-run stall only; do not stop, relaunch, replace, or harvest while the external surface still shows active research.
- 2026-05-17T19:49:41-06:00: Run 07 remains active and moved into final synthesis. Visible progress remains step 1 complete and step 2 active; status text changed to `Synthesizing final result with citations...`; visible count remains `11 searches`; the card also shows `11 sources searched`; `Stop research` remains present. Report is not ready to harvest.
- 2026-05-17T20:05:20-06:00: Run 07 completed in ChatGPT Deep Research. Visible report metadata: `Research completed in 1h 12m`, `14 citations`, `9 searches`, `17 May • 14 sources`; title `OfOne Post-Run Benchmark Hardening Review`. Export/copy controls were blocked by the available automation path, so the report was harvested from visible completed report content into `research/results/2026-05-17-07-ofone-post-run06-hardening-review-result.md`; local synthesis saved to `research/results/2026-05-17-07-ofone-post-run06-hardening-review-synthesis.md`.
- 2026-05-17T20:24:15-06:00: Run 07 accepted as benchmark-hardening counsel and integrated locally. Accepted items implemented: `benchmark_trace` case-file, prompt-file, and input-bundle hash binding; execution-matrix `rerun_policy`; per-excluded-run `rerun_plan`; stronger `superiorityReady()` checks against released aggregate-eligible evidence; public benchmark checker attestation; negative benchmark regressions; README/Pages links. Next mode is `benchmark_handoff`, not another broad architecture review.
- 2026-05-17T21:05:00-06:00: Benchmark handoff progressed into the first remedial execution step. Produced remedial `full_ofone` rerun 1 for `case-strategic-gated-diligence-001` with case-native raw output, artifact JSON, computed validator JSON, rendering, patch report, and local review. The original excluded full-OfOne output remains immutable evidence; the remedial rerun is tracked outside the original 90-slot count and aggregate-eligible only as a replacement after publication and continued benchmark controls.
- 2026-05-17T21:45:00-06:00: Broader Batch 01 execution resumed locally. Produced `case-scientific-mechanism-check-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 1 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne scientific artifact validates as Map mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, and review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 6 completed and 6 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun.
- 2026-05-17T21:49:40-06:00: GitHub Pages parity was rechecked after public commit `5ce8575`. The scientific mechanism slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, rendering, patch report, and local review. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-17T22:10:14-06:00: Produced `case-regulated-wastewater-market-entry-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 1 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne regulated wastewater artifact validates as Map mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, and review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 9 completed and 9 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun. Publication and Pages parity are still pending until this batch is committed and pushed.
- 2026-05-17T22:14:38-06:00: GitHub Pages parity passed after public commit `97d5fbb`. The regulated wastewater slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, rendering, patch report, and local review. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-17T22:26:00-06:00: Produced `case-formal-proof-search-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 1 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne formal artifact validates as Map mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, and review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 12 completed and 12 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun. Publication and Pages parity are still pending until this batch is committed and pushed.
- 2026-05-17T22:28:38-06:00: GitHub Pages parity passed after public commit `9d3faca`. The formal proof-search slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, rendering, patch report, and local review. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-17T22:40:00-06:00: Produced `case-public-sector-ai-policy-audit-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 1 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne policy artifact validates as Audit mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, review-log, and local review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 15 completed and 15 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun. Publication and Pages parity are still pending until this batch is committed and pushed.
- 2026-05-17T22:47:03-06:00: GitHub Pages parity passed after public commit `d337108`. The public-sector AI policy audit slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, Audit rendering, patch report, and local reviews. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-18T01:55:00-06:00: Produced `case-strategic-gated-diligence-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 2 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne strategic repeat-2 artifact validates as Map mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, and local review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 18 completed and 18 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun.
- 2026-05-18T02:04:49-06:00: GitHub Pages parity passed after public commit `732c6c8`. The strategic gated diligence repeat-2 slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, Map rendering, patch report, and local reviews. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-18T02:31:35-06:00: Produced `case-scientific-mechanism-check-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 2 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne scientific repeat-2 artifact validates as Map mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, and local review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 21 completed and 21 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun.
- 2026-05-18T02:36:12-06:00: GitHub Pages parity passed after public commit `7694e7f`. The scientific mechanism repeat-2 slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, Map rendering, patch report, and local reviews. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-18T02:52:00-06:00: Produced `case-regulated-wastewater-market-entry-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 2 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne regulated wastewater repeat-2 artifact validates as Map mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, and local review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 24 completed and 24 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun. Publication and Pages parity are still pending until this batch is committed and pushed.
- 2026-05-18T02:59:20-06:00: GitHub Pages parity passed after public commit `f62f7c9`. The regulated wastewater repeat-2 slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, Map rendering, patch report, and local reviews. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-18T03:07:00-06:00: Produced `case-formal-proof-search-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 2 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne formal repeat-2 artifact validates as Map mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, and local review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 27 completed and 27 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun. Publication and Pages parity are still pending until this batch is committed and pushed.
- 2026-05-18T03:12:20-06:00: GitHub Pages parity passed after public commit `2287da0`. The formal proof-search repeat-2 slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, Map rendering, patch report, and local reviews. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-18T03:20:24-06:00: Produced `case-public-sector-ai-policy-audit-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 2 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne policy repeat-2 artifact validates as Audit mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, review-log, and local review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 30 completed and 30 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun. Publication and Pages parity are still pending until this batch is committed and pushed.
- 2026-05-18T03:30:42-06:00: GitHub Pages parity passed after public commit `4499601`. The public-sector AI policy audit repeat-2 slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, Audit rendering, patch report, and local reviews. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-18T03:35:25-06:00: Produced `case-strategic-gated-diligence-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 3 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne strategic repeat-3 artifact validates as Map mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, and local review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 33 completed and 33 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun. Publication and Pages parity are still pending until this batch is committed and pushed.
- 2026-05-18T03:45:02-06:00: GitHub Pages parity passed after public commit `83a68e9`. The strategic gated diligence repeat-3 slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, Map rendering, patch report, and local reviews. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-18T03:52:00-06:00: Produced `case-scientific-mechanism-check-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 3 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne scientific repeat-3 artifact validates as Map mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, and local review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 36 completed and 36 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun. Publication and Pages parity are still pending until this batch is committed and pushed.
- 2026-05-18T03:58:42-06:00: GitHub Pages parity passed after public commit `b770b96`. The scientific mechanism repeat-3 slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, Map rendering, patch report, and local reviews. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-18T04:12:38-06:00: Produced `case-regulated-wastewater-market-entry-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 3 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne regulated wastewater repeat-3 artifact validates as Map mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, and local review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 39 completed and 39 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun. Publication and Pages parity are still pending until this batch is committed and pushed.
- 2026-05-18T04:15:00-06:00: GitHub Pages parity passed after public commit `046282e`. The regulated wastewater repeat-3 slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, Map rendering, patch report, and local reviews. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-18T04:20:27-06:00: Produced `case-formal-proof-search-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 3 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne formal repeat-3 artifact validates as Map mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, and local review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 42 completed and 42 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun. Publication and Pages parity are still pending until this batch is committed and pushed.
- 2026-05-18T04:31:29-06:00: GitHub Pages parity passed after public commit `35fdd24`. The formal proof-search repeat-3 slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, Map rendering, patch report, and local reviews. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-18T04:40:31-06:00: Produced `case-public-sector-ai-policy-audit-001` / `agentic_coding` / repeat 3 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. The full-OfOne policy repeat-3 artifact validates as Audit mode, carries artifact-level benchmark trace binding, and has validator, rendering, patch, review-log, and local review artifacts. Execution matrix now records 45 completed and 45 reviewed original slots, 1 excluded original, and 1 remedial rerun. Publication and Pages parity are still pending until this batch is committed and pushed.
- 2026-05-18T04:44:53-06:00: GitHub Pages parity passed after public commit `bb8b474`. The public-sector AI policy audit repeat-3 slice is now published and Pages-confirmed across raw outputs, full-OfOne artifact, validator, Audit rendering, patch report, review-log objects, and local reviews. Current mode remains `benchmark_handoff`; the next bounded action is continued Batch 01 benchmark execution, not another broad architecture Deep Research run.
- 2026-05-18T04:53:54-06:00: Prepared the next frontier reasoning benchmark run packet for `case-strategic-gated-diligence-001` / repeat 1 across direct-answer, light-structured, and full-OfOne arms. No `frontier_reasoning` run slots are marked completed because the current tool surface lacks a clean Chrome plugin / Deep Research launch path that can verify ChatGPT model label, reasoning mode, Deep Research state, clean-chat isolation, independent arm execution, active research state, and stop-control evidence. The packet is paste-ready at `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/frontier-run-packets/2026-05-18-strategic-gated-diligence-frontier-r1.md`.
- 2026-05-18T05:03:00-06:00: Public commit `4651b84` pushed the prepared frontier run packet and its public references. `npm run pages:check` initially saw a transient homepage hash mismatch while the packet itself already matched Pages; after retry, GitHub Pages parity passed across the homepage, the frontier packet, tracker, Run 07 ledger, recursive loop doc, and Batch 01 benchmark surfaces. No frontier outputs were harvested or marked complete.
- 2026-05-20T17:05:04-06:00: Launched the first `frontier_reasoning` run from the prepared packet: `case-strategic-gated-diligence-001` / `direct_answer` / repeat 1 at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0e3e09-fd6c-83e8-a914-36445d70d090. Launch proof: clean new ChatGPT conversation, observed `Latest • 5.5`, selected `Pro • Extended`, Deep Research enabled, prompt submitted, generated plan title `Reversible diligence decision plan`, `Start` clicked, visible `Researching...` state, and `Stop research` present. This is launch proof only; no frontier output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-20T17:09:46-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress. Visible material progress: status text `Determining the screenshot requirements...`, count `60 searches`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so do not harvest, launch a replacement, mark a slot complete, or update aggregate eligibility.
- 2026-05-20T17:12:33-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress. Visible material progress: status text changed to `Finalizing information sources and decisions...`, count remains `60 searches`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so do not harvest, launch a replacement, mark a slot complete, or update aggregate eligibility.
- 2026-05-20T17:14:45-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress. Visible material progress: the first plan step now shows complete, status text remains `Finalizing information sources and decisions...`, count remains `60 searches`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so do not harvest, launch a replacement, mark a slot complete, or update aggregate eligibility.
- 2026-05-20T17:29:08-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress. Visible material progress: status text changed to `Drafting output format for clarity...`, count remains `60 searches`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so do not harvest, launch a replacement, mark a slot complete, or update aggregate eligibility.
- 2026-05-20T17:46:00-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress and unchanged past the 15-minute watchdog threshold. Visible status text remains `Drafting output format for clarity...`, count remains `60 searches`, and the square stop-control remains present. Treat as a possible active-run stall only; do not harvest, stop, relaunch, mark a slot complete, or update aggregate eligibility while stop-control remains visible.
- 2026-05-20T18:05:39-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress and unchanged beyond the next watchdog interval. Visible plan title remains `Reversible diligence decision plan`; visible status text remains `Drafting output format for clarity...`; visible count remains `60 searches`; the square stop-control remains present. Treat as continued active-run stall evidence only; no completed report is visible, and no `frontier_reasoning` output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-20T18:21:46-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run resumed visible movement. Visible plan title remains `Reversible diligence decision plan`; visible status text changed to `Researching...`; visible count advanced to `81 searches`; the square stop-control remains present. No completed report is visible, so do not harvest, stop, relaunch, mark a slot complete, or update aggregate eligibility.
- 2026-05-20T18:43:46-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress and unchanged beyond the watchdog interval. Visible plan title remains `Reversible diligence decision plan`; visible status text remains `Researching...`; visible count remains `81 searches`; the square stop-control remains present. Treat as active-run stall evidence only; no completed report is visible, and no `frontier_reasoning` output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-20T18:59:20-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress and unchanged beyond the watchdog interval. Visible plan title remains `Reversible diligence decision plan`; visible status text remains `Researching...`; visible count remains `81 searches`; the square stop-control remains present. Treat as continued active-run stall evidence only; no completed report is visible, and no `frontier_reasoning` output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-20T19:15:13-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress and unchanged beyond the watchdog interval. Visible plan title remains `Reversible diligence decision plan`; visible status text remains `Researching...`; visible count remains `81 searches`; the square stop-control remains present. Treat as continued active-run stall evidence only; no completed report is visible, and no `frontier_reasoning` output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-20T19:30:14-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress and unchanged beyond the watchdog interval. Visible plan title remains `Reversible diligence decision plan`; visible status text remains `Researching...`; visible count remains `81 searches`; the square stop-control remains present. Treat as continued active-run stall evidence only; no completed report is visible, and no `frontier_reasoning` output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-20T19:45:32-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress and unchanged beyond the watchdog interval. Visible plan title remains `Reversible diligence decision plan`; step 1 remains checked complete and step 2 remains active; visible status text remains `Researching...`; visible count remains `81 searches`; the square stop-control remains present. Treat as continued active-run stall evidence only; no completed report is visible, and no `frontier_reasoning` output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-20T20:03:05-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress and unchanged beyond the watchdog interval. Visible plan title remains `Reversible diligence decision plan`; step 1 remains checked complete and step 2 remains active; visible status text remains `Researching...`; visible count remains `81 searches`; the square stop-control remains present. Treat as continued active-run stall evidence only; no completed report is visible, and no `frontier_reasoning` output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-20T20:19:18-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress and unchanged beyond the watchdog interval. Visible plan title remains `Reversible diligence decision plan`; step 1 remains checked complete and step 2 remains active; visible status text remains `Researching...`; visible count remains `81 searches`; the square stop-control remains present. Treat as continued active-run stall evidence only; no completed report is visible, and no `frontier_reasoning` output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-20T20:34:32-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run remains in progress and unchanged beyond the watchdog interval. Visible plan title remains `Reversible diligence decision plan`; step 1 remains checked complete and step 2 remains active; visible status text remains `Researching...`; visible count remains `81 searches`; the square stop-control remains present. Treat as continued active-run stall evidence only; no completed report is visible, and no `frontier_reasoning` output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-20T20:44:10-06:00: The `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer conversation is still reachable at the expected ChatGPT URL, but the visible surface has materially changed and is not harvest proof. Visible plan title remains `Reversible diligence decision plan`; step 1 remains checked complete and step 2 remains active; the plan card now shows an `Update` button and the composer is enabled. No `Researching...` status text, search count, or square stop-control is visible in the captured viewport, and no completed report is visible. Treat as an ambiguous external-run state requiring continued observation; do not harvest, relaunch, mark a `frontier_reasoning` slot complete, or update aggregate eligibility from this evidence.
- 2026-05-20T21:16:00-06:00: The `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run completed in ChatGPT Deep Research. Visible metadata: `Research completed in 17m`, `6 citations`, `81 searches`, title `Benchmark Raw Output`. Exported Markdown source `/Users/jamesbrady/Downloads/deep-research-report (32).md` was copied to `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/outputs/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__direct_answer__frontier_reasoning__r1.md` with SHA-256 `1647be401efc3069e61c763ed619e7c8cd29c3f212cb1e993d17457a7c4e44e2`. Local review was added at `benchmarks/reviews/2026-05-17-batch-01/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__direct_answer__frontier_reasoning__r1.md`; the slot is completed/reviewed/aggregate-eligible locally pending commit, push, and Pages confirmation.
- 2026-05-20T21:28:43-06:00: The `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run is now committed, pushed, and Pages-confirmed. Launched the next clean isolated frontier arm, `case-strategic-gated-diligence-001` / `light_structured` / repeat 1, at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0e7bcd-43b0-83e8-9a92-5195521c42fe. Launch proof: clean new ChatGPT conversation, observed `Latest • 5.5`, selected `Pro • Extended`, Deep Research enabled, prompt submitted, generated plan title `Reversible diligence decision plan`, `Start` clicked, visible `Researching...`, and `Stop research` present. This is launch proof only; no light-structured frontier output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-20T21:36:41-06:00: The `frontier_reasoning` light-structured conversation is reachable at the expected URL, but the visible surface has materially changed and is not harvest proof. Visible plan title remains `Reversible diligence decision plan`; step 1 is checked complete and step 2 is active; the plan card shows an `Update` button and the composer is enabled with text `Get a detailed report`. No `Researching...` status text, search count, square stop-control, or completed report is visible in the captured viewport. Treat as an ambiguous external-run state requiring continued observation; do not harvest, relaunch, mark the light-structured frontier slot complete, update aggregate eligibility, or launch the full-OfOne frontier arm from this evidence.
- 2026-05-20T21:43:46-06:00: The `frontier_reasoning` light-structured run completed in ChatGPT Deep Research. Visible completed report title `Benchmark Raw Output`; visible run metadata includes `Run ID: 2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__light_structured__frontier_reasoning__r1` and `Status: completed`. Export to Markdown succeeded as `/Users/jamesbrady/Downloads/deep-research-report (33).md`, and the exported Markdown was copied to `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/outputs/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__light_structured__frontier_reasoning__r1.md` with SHA-256 `f70a55a9dee97cebc5d0138f57ef887c948dabc452fb2071dec4624fd13b55e6`. Local review was added at `benchmarks/reviews/2026-05-17-batch-01/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__light_structured__frontier_reasoning__r1.md`; the slot is completed/reviewed/aggregate-eligible locally pending commit, push, and Pages confirmation.
- 2026-05-20T21:55:55-06:00: Commit `7d3f545` pushed the `frontier_reasoning` light-structured harvest, local review, execution-matrix update, checker attestation, public links, and status updates. Required local checks passed before commit: `npm run schema:check`, `npm run validate`, `npm run review:check`, `npm run research:check`, `npm run benchmark`, `npm test`, and `git diff --check`; `npm run benchmark` preserved the expected superiority-blocking warning. `npm run pages:check` initially saw transient homepage and execution-matrix mismatches during deployment, then passed after GitHub Pages caught up. The full-OfOne frontier arm may now be launched only with fresh clean-conversation launch proof.
- 2026-05-20T22:05:29-06:00: Launched the third clean `frontier_reasoning` strategic repeat-1 arm, `case-strategic-gated-diligence-001` / `full_ofone` / repeat 1, at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0e8476-9f6c-83e8-b201-ff3f97fae18b. Launch proof: clean new ChatGPT conversation, prompt run metadata visible for `2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1`, observed model selector `Latest • 5.5` with selected `Pro • Extended`, Deep Research enabled, generated plan title `Reversible diligence decision plan`, `Start` clicked, visible `Researching...`, and `Stop research` present. This is launch proof only; no completed report is visible, and no full-OfOne frontier output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-20T22:07:33-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne run shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Reversible diligence decision plan`; step 1 is checked complete, step 2 is active, visible status text is `Searching for the benchmarkTrace schema...`, visible count shows `5 searches` and `5 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so do not harvest, relaunch, mark the slot complete, or update aggregate eligibility.
- 2026-05-20T22:09:12-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne run remains in progress with material status text changed to `Considering optional fields for validation...`; step 1 remains checked complete, step 2 remains active, visible count remains `5 searches` and `5 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so do not harvest or mark the slot complete.
- 2026-05-20T22:10:29-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne run remains in progress with visible status text changed to `Reviewing gating requirements and schema...`; step 1 remains checked complete, step 2 remains active, visible count remains `5 searches` and `5 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so do not harvest or mark the slot complete.
- 2026-05-20T22:12:11-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne run remains in progress with visible status text changed to `Considering claim edges and operational blocks...`; step 1 remains checked complete, step 2 remains active, visible count advanced to `9 searches` and `9 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so do not harvest or mark the slot complete.
- 2026-05-20T22:17:53-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne run remains in progress with visible status text changed to `Modeling actors and criteria with gates...`; step 1 remains checked complete, step 2 remains active, visible count remains `9 searches` and `9 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so do not harvest or mark the slot complete.
- 2026-05-20T22:22:38-06:00: The active `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne run remains in progress with visible status text changed to `Finalizing output structure and validation details...`; step 1 remains checked complete, step 2 remains active, visible count remains `9 searches` and `9 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so do not harvest or mark the slot complete.
- 2026-05-20T22:29:37-06:00: The `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne run completed in ChatGPT Deep Research. Visible metadata: `Research completed in 18m`, `5 citations`, `9 searches`, `20 May • 5 sources`, title `Benchmark Raw Output`, and run metadata `Status: completed`. Exported Markdown source `/Users/jamesbrady/Downloads/deep-research-report (34).md` was copied to `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/outputs/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1.md` with SHA-256 `227ffdc008b9db9c0facac6de0303d1fd1575f295e8f82da91ce7078014b555a`. Extracted artifact JSON, computed validator JSON, rendering, patch report, and local review were added. The slot is completed/reviewed but excluded before aggregate scoring because computed local validation failed semantic graph checks and contradicted the artifact's self-attested validator pass.
- 2026-05-20T22:50:33-06:00: Launched the remedial `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne rerun for `case-strategic-gated-diligence-001` / repeat 1 at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0e8efd-2234-83e8-af43-a7e25266034d. Launch proof: clean ChatGPT root/new-chat state before submission, observed model selector `Latest • 5.5` with selected `Pro • Extended`, Deep Research enabled, benchmark packet delivered as `Pasted text(12).txt`, visible instruction included run ID `2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1__rerun1`, generated plan title `Strategic gated diligence`, `Start` clicked, visible `Researching...`, and `Stop research` present. This is launch proof only; no completed report is visible, and no remedial output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-20T22:52:32-06:00: The active remedial `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne rerun shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; visible status text changed to `Planning deep research and citation strategy...`; `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so do not harvest, relaunch, mark the remedial run complete, or update aggregate eligibility.
- 2026-05-20T22:54:18-06:00: The active remedial `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne rerun shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; visible status text changed to `Inspecting relevant docs and contracts...`; `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so do not harvest, relaunch, mark the remedial run complete, or update aggregate eligibility.
- 2026-05-20T23:11:54-06:00: The active remedial `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne rerun remains active after extended observation. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is complete and step 2 is active; visible status text is `Clarifying data needs and recommendations...`; visible count shows `49 searches` and `49 sources searched`; `Stop research` remains present. Treat as active-run observation only; no completed report is visible, so do not harvest, relaunch, mark the remedial run complete, or update aggregate eligibility.
- 2026-05-20T23:21:50-06:00: The active remedial `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne rerun remains active with material status progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is complete and step 2 is active; visible status text changed to `Considering frameworks and resources...`; visible count remains `49 searches` and `49 sources searched`; `Stop research` remains present. Treat as active-run observation only; no completed report is visible, so do not harvest, relaunch, mark the remedial run complete, or update aggregate eligibility.
- 2026-05-20T23:26:59-06:00: The active remedial `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne rerun remains active with material status progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is complete and step 2 is active; visible status text changed to `Clarifying source review protocols...`; visible count remains `49 searches` and `49 sources searched`; `Stop research` remains present. Treat as active-run observation only; no completed report is visible, so do not harvest, relaunch, mark the remedial run complete, or update aggregate eligibility.
- 2026-05-20T23:43:56-06:00: The active remedial `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne rerun remains active and unchanged past the watchdog threshold. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is complete and step 2 is active; visible status text remains `Clarifying source review protocols...`; visible count remains `49 searches` and `49 sources searched`; `Stop research` remains present. Treat as possible active-run stall evidence only; no completed report is visible, so do not harvest, relaunch, mark the remedial run complete, or update aggregate eligibility.
- 2026-05-21T03:34:00-06:00: Same-shape Deep Research remedial reruns for the frontier full-OfOne strategic repeat-1 slot are now barred by `research/frontier-full-ofone-repair-protocol.md`. The controlled non-Deep-Research execution contract at `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/frontier-run-packets/2026-05-21-strategic-gated-diligence-frontier-full-r1-mode-a-contract.md` produced `2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1__rerun5` with raw output, artifact JSON, computed validator JSON, rendering, patch report, and local review. The computed validator passed with only the expected superiority-readiness warning. The execution matrix records rerun5 under `remedial_runs` as `replace_for_aggregate_only`; the original excluded run remains immutable and failed reruns 1-4 remain outside aggregate scoring. Publication and Pages parity are still pending until this batch is committed and pushed.
- 2026-05-21T00:02:00-06:00: The remedial `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne rerun completed in ChatGPT Deep Research. Visible metadata: `Research completed in 1h 7m`, `10 citations`, `117 searches`, `20 May`, `10 sources`, title `Strategic Gated Diligence Remedial Run Research Report`. Exported Markdown source `/Users/jamesbrady/Downloads/deep-research-report (36).md` was copied to `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/outputs/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1__rerun1.md` with SHA-256 `c0900989fe10e528648ea57d6f20f1f18f662fcff89bb04194bbc99fb5a9d385`. Local contract scan found no exact `# Benchmark Raw Output`, `Run ID:`, `Status: completed`, `## Artifact JSON`, fenced JSON artifact, `## Validator Result`, `## Rendering`, or `## Patch Report` sections. The run is rejected before artifact extraction, matrix insertion, review aggregate eligibility, or any superiority comparison.
- 2026-05-21T00:12:00-06:00: Prepared stricter remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 2 packet at `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/frontier-run-packets/2026-05-21-strategic-gated-diligence-frontier-full-r1-rerun2.md`. Status is `prepared_not_launched`; no ChatGPT conversation, harvest, review, or aggregate eligibility exists yet.
- 2026-05-21T00:17:38-06:00: Launched remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 2 at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0ea350-3584-83e8-9d3e-ab7759c489f6. Launch proof: clean ChatGPT root/new-chat surface before submission, clean composer initially showed `Extended Pro`, Deep Research was enabled and the composer then showed `Pro`, packet delivered as `Pasted text(13).txt`, visible instruction named run ID `2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1__rerun2`, generated plan title `Strategic gated diligence`, `Start` clicked, visible `Researching...`, and `Stop research` present. This is launch proof only; no completed report is visible, and no rerun 2 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T00:21:12-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 2 shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is checked complete, step 2 is active, status text is `Opening lines to inspect key fields...`, count shows `17 searches` and `17 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 2 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T00:25:58-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 2 remains in progress with material status progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is checked complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Considering search options for codeload URL...`, count remains `17 searches` and `17 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 2 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T00:29:08-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 2 remains in progress with material status progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is checked complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Considering evidence hash computation...`, count remains `17 searches` and `17 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 2 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T00:31:47-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 2 remains in progress with material status progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is checked complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Inspecting example files...`, count remains `17 searches` and `17 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 2 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T00:34:58-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 2 remains in progress with material status progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is checked complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Looking for confidence_model shape and movement_jobs...`, count remains `17 searches` and `17 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 2 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T00:38:27-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 2 remains in progress with material status progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is checked complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Completing evidence and permissions setup...`, count advanced to `20 searches` and `20 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 2 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T00:41:15-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 2 remains in progress with material status progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is checked complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Streamlining evidence and claim relationships...`, count remains `20 searches` and `20 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 2 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T00:45:04-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 2 remains in progress with material status progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is checked complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Defining criteria and actor roles for decision-making...`, count remains `20 searches` and `20 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 2 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T00:49:21-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 2 remains in progress with material status progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is checked complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Citing official documentation and validation details...`, count remains `20 searches` and `20 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 2 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T00:55:48-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 2 remains in progress with material status progress. Visible plan title remains `Strategic gated diligence`; step 1 is checked complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Refining duplicate detection and potential risks...`, count remains `20 searches` and `20 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 2 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T01:08:00-06:00: Remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 2 completed in ChatGPT Deep Research. Visible metadata: `Research completed in 44m`, `1 citation`, `20 searches`, `21 May`, `1 source`, title `Benchmark Raw Output`, and run metadata `Status: completed`. Exported Markdown source `/Users/jamesbrady/Downloads/deep-research-report (37).md` was copied to `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/outputs/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1__rerun2.md` with SHA-256 `dfdae1034abf0e0521df5103bfa297c605ac5ef149b4a3f85490f070e7179bd8`. Extracted artifact JSON, computed validator JSON, rendering, patch report, and local review were added. Local validation failed because evidence `E1`, `E2`, and `E3` lack required `movement_jobs` fields and the tradeoff surface has a reversal-condition defect around `G1`; the run is rejected before aggregate scoring and is not inserted into the execution matrix.
- 2026-05-21T01:22:17-06:00: Prepared remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 3 packet at `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/frontier-run-packets/2026-05-21-strategic-gated-diligence-frontier-full-r1-rerun3.md` and corrected the `docs/object-schemas.md` Evidence example to include required `movement_jobs`. Status is `prepared_not_launched`; no ChatGPT conversation, harvest, review, execution-matrix insertion, aggregate eligibility, aggregate comparison, or superiority claim exists yet.
- 2026-05-21T01:35:43-06:00: Launched remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 3 at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0eb57b-6b08-83e8-a3e2-16e26adc497f. Launch proof: clean ChatGPT root/new-chat surface before submission, observed model selector `Latest - 5.5` with selected `Pro - Extended`, Deep Research enabled, packet delivered as `Pasted text(14).txt`, visible instruction to run the attached OfOne benchmark packet exactly as the prompt, generated plan title `Run OfOne benchmark packet`, `Start` clicked, visible `Researching...`, and `Stop research` present. This is launch proof only; no completed report is visible, and no rerun 3 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, matrix-inserted, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T01:39:00-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 3 shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Run OfOne benchmark packet`; the first plan step is complete, the second step is active, status text is `Considering how to parse and combine schemas...`, count shows `2 searches` and `2 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 3 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, matrix-inserted, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T01:42:59-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 3 shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Run OfOne benchmark packet`; the first plan step remains complete, the second step remains active, status text changed to `Looking into scene token examples...`, count advanced to `23 searches` and `23 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 3 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, matrix-inserted, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T01:50:52-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 3 shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Run OfOne benchmark packet`; the first plan step remains complete, the second step remains active, status text changed to `Inspecting example structure and review considerations...`, count remains `23 searches` and `23 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 3 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, matrix-inserted, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T01:58:41-06:00: Remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 3 completed in ChatGPT Deep Research. Visible metadata: `Research completed in 19m`, `5 citations`, `23 searches`, `21 May`, `5 sources`, title `Benchmark Raw Output`, and report status field `completed`. Exported Markdown source `/Users/jamesbrady/Downloads/deep-research-report (38).md` was copied to `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/outputs/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1__rerun3.md` with SHA-256 `b64a604e28a5e26d871dc5bca05e4be33dd0630afbbfca8d3d28cbc579e7db85`. Extracted artifact JSON, computed validator JSON, rendering, patch report, and local review were added. Local validation failed because `benchmark_trace` lacks required current-schema fields and edges `X2`, `X3`, and `X4` use illegal endpoint/relation combinations; the raw export also omitted exact top-level run metadata required by the packet. The run is rejected before aggregate scoring and remains outside `remedial_runs`.
- 2026-05-21T02:18:00-06:00: Prepared remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 4 packet at `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/frontier-run-packets/2026-05-21-strategic-gated-diligence-frontier-full-r1-rerun4.md`. Added `npm run frontier:check` local packet preflight and passed it against the rerun 4 packet. Status is `prepared_not_launched`; no ChatGPT conversation, launch proof, harvest, review, execution-matrix insertion, aggregate eligibility, aggregate comparison, or superiority claim exists yet.
- 2026-05-21T02:22:25-06:00: Launched remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 4 at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0ec0a2-3814-83e8-8f86-23b625eace67 after `npm run frontier:check` and `npm run pages:check` both passed. Launch proof: clean ChatGPT root/new-chat surface before submission, observed model selector `Latest • 5.5` with selected `Pro • Extended`, Deep Research enabled, packet delivered as `Pasted markdown(1).md`, visible instruction to run the attached OfOne benchmark packet exactly as the prompt, generated plan title `Run OfOne benchmark packet`, `Start` clicked, visible `Researching...`, and `Stop research` present. This is launch proof only; no completed report is visible, and no rerun 4 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, matrix-inserted, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T02:24:37-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 4 shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Run OfOne benchmark packet`; the first plan step is complete, the second step is active, status text is `Exploring benchmark formats and documents...`, count shows `31 searches` and `31 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 4 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, matrix-inserted, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T02:26:48-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 4 shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Run OfOne benchmark packet`; the first plan step is complete, the second step is active, status text changed to `Clarifying "Prompt section" interpretations...`, count shows `30 searches` and `30 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 4 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, matrix-inserted, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T02:29:55-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 4 shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Run OfOne benchmark packet`; the first plan step is complete, the second step is active, status text changed to `Exploring legality examples and endpoint object types...`, count shows `31 searches` and `31 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 4 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, matrix-inserted, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T02:34:00-06:00: The active remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 4 shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Run OfOne benchmark packet`; the first plan step remains complete, the second step remains active, status text changed to `Clarifying metadata statuses and assumptions...`, count remains `31 searches` and `31 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and no rerun 4 output is harvested, reviewed, complete, matrix-inserted, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T02:44:16-06:00: Remedial frontier full-OfOne rerun 4 completed in ChatGPT Deep Research. Visible metadata: `Research completed in 18m`, `12 citations`, `28 searches`, `21 May`, `12 sources`, title `Running an Unspecified OfOne Benchmark Packet Exactly`. Exported Markdown source `/Users/jamesbrady/Downloads/deep-research-report (39).md` was copied to `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/outputs/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-strategic-gated-diligence-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1__rerun4.md` with SHA-256 `5d4de650a1c2f3f6612b718f45e7313f40433dfaf851afeaad1b3ca0f9dbd702`. Local contract scan found no exact `# Benchmark Raw Output`, actual rerun 4 `Run ID:`, actual `Status: completed`, actual case-bound `## Artifact JSON`, actual `## Validator Result`, actual `## Rendering`, or actual `## Patch Report` sections. The run is rejected before artifact extraction, execution-matrix replacement insertion, aggregate eligibility, aggregate comparison, or any superiority claim.
- 2026-05-21T02:54:27-06:00: Added the frontier full-OfOne repair protocol at `research/frontier-full-ofone-repair-protocol.md` with executable guard `npm run frontier:protocol:check`. The protocol converts the repeated rerun failure into a process gate: no further same-shape attachment-led Deep Research remedial rerun is allowed for this slot. The next eligible path is controlled non-Deep-Research execution or a fully inline Deep Research launch contract, followed by computed local validation, local review, publication, and Pages parity before any replacement or aggregate eligibility.
- 2026-05-21T03:02:51-06:00: Prepared the Mode A controlled execution contract for the unrepaired frontier full-OfOne slot at `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/frontier-run-packets/2026-05-21-strategic-gated-diligence-frontier-full-r1-mode-a-contract.md` and added executable guard `npm run frontier:controlled:check`. The contract freezes rerun 5, exact source hashes, required package sections, and the matrix non-insertion guard. It is prepared only: no controlled output exists, no harvest/review exists, no `remedial_runs` insertion exists, no aggregate eligibility exists, and superiority claims remain blocked.
- 2026-05-21T03:35:00-06:00: Public commit `7068ea8` pushed the controlled frontier full-OfOne rerun5 package. `npm run pages:check` passed after Pages caught up, confirming public parity for the rerun5 raw output, artifact JSON, computed validator JSON, rendering, patch report, local review, execution matrix, tracker, recursive loop, and public index links. The next predeclared frontier slot is `case-regulated-wastewater-market-entry-001` / `frontier_reasoning` / repeat 1; prepare or launch it only with clean Deep Research launch proof.
- 2026-05-21T03:44:32-06:00: Launched the Batch 01 `frontier_reasoning` regulated wastewater direct-answer repeat-1 arm in a clean ChatGPT Deep Research conversation at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0ed3db-cccc-83e8-b84c-b3b1cb7b0bfa. Launch proof: clean ChatGPT root/new-chat surface before submission, observed model selector `Latest • 5.5` with selected `Pro • Extended`, Deep Research enabled, prompt metadata visible for `2026-05-17-batch-01__case-regulated-wastewater-market-entry-001__direct_answer__frontier_reasoning__r1`, generated plan title `Regulated wastewater market entry`, `Start` clicked, visible `Researching...`, and `Stop research` present. This is launch proof only; no completed report is visible, and no regulated wastewater frontier output is harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T03:46:42-06:00: The active regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run shows material progress. Visible status text changed to `Looking into state-specific operator certification requirements...`; plan title remains `Regulated wastewater market entry`; `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and the slot is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T03:51:36-06:00: The active regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer run shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Regulated wastewater market entry`; status text changed to `Refining final recommendation structure...`; count advanced to `266 searches` / `266 sources searched`; `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, and the slot is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T03:58:46-06:00: The regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer repeat-1 arm completed in ChatGPT Deep Research. Visible metadata: `Research completed in 12m`, `16 citations`, `319 searches`, `21 May`, `16 sources`, title `Benchmark Raw Output`, and run metadata `Status: completed`. Exported Markdown source `/Users/jamesbrady/Downloads/deep-research-report (40).md` was copied to `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/outputs/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-regulated-wastewater-market-entry-001__direct_answer__frontier_reasoning__r1.md` with SHA-256 `afc97b5a4ba4f92eaa8c1c41470e56016ba71dbd9fa7a3a5315770605db80147`. Local review was added at `benchmarks/reviews/2026-05-17-batch-01/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-regulated-wastewater-market-entry-001__direct_answer__frontier_reasoning__r1.md`; the slot passed pre-score compliance and is represented in the matrix/page-link targets for publication parity checking. The regulated wastewater light-structured and full-OfOne frontier arms are not launched.
- 2026-05-21T04:12:23-06:00: Launched the Batch 01 `frontier_reasoning` regulated wastewater light-structured repeat-1 arm in a clean ChatGPT Deep Research conversation at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0eda60-dc18-83e8-a888-e9e8ac1ab1fe. Launch proof: clean ChatGPT root/new-chat surface before submission, composer showed `Extended Pro` before Deep Research selection and `Pro` after Deep Research was enabled, prompt metadata visible for `2026-05-17-batch-01__case-regulated-wastewater-market-entry-001__light_structured__frontier_reasoning__r1`, generated plan title `Regulated wastewater market entry`, `Start` clicked, visible `Researching...`, and `Stop research` present. This is launch proof only; no completed report is visible, and the light-structured output is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible. The regulated wastewater full-OfOne frontier arm is not launched.
- 2026-05-21T04:15:55-06:00: The active regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` light-structured repeat-1 run shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Regulated wastewater market entry`; step 1 is complete, step 2 is active, status text is `Clarifying permit process and responsibilities...`, count shows `106 searches` and `106 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so the light-structured output is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T04:17:05-06:00: The active regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` light-structured repeat-1 run shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Regulated wastewater market entry`; step 1 is complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Considering state opportunities for advanced treatment markets...`, count advanced to `188 searches` and `188 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so the light-structured output is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T04:26:18-06:00: The active regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` light-structured repeat-1 run remains in progress. Visible plan title remains `Regulated wastewater market entry`; step 1 is complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Clarifying California requirements and public involvement processes...`, count remains `188 searches` and `188 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so the light-structured output is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T04:36:36-06:00: The regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` light-structured repeat-1 arm completed in ChatGPT Deep Research. Visible metadata: `Research completed in 22m`, `15 citations`, `236 searches`, `21 May`, `15 sources`, title `Benchmark Raw Output`, and run metadata `Status: completed`. Exported Markdown source `/Users/jamesbrady/Downloads/deep-research-report (41).md` was copied to `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/outputs/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-regulated-wastewater-market-entry-001__light_structured__frontier_reasoning__r1.md` with SHA-256 `cf4eb63a53dc211ea09bb51030e3771129207cbe4e81f9c231388299fbeb9042`. Local review was added at `benchmarks/reviews/2026-05-17-batch-01/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-regulated-wastewater-market-entry-001__light_structured__frontier_reasoning__r1.md`; the slot passed pre-score compliance and is represented in the matrix/page-link targets for publication parity checking. The regulated wastewater full-OfOne frontier arm is not launched.
- 2026-05-21T04:50:12-06:00: Commit `1ffcf96` pushed the regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` light-structured harvest, local review, execution-matrix update, checker attestation, public links, and status updates. Required local verification passed before commit: `git diff --check`, `npm run schema:check`, `npm run validate`, `npm run review:check`, `npm run research:check`, `npm run benchmark`, `npm test`, `npm run frontier:protocol:check`, and `npm run frontier:controlled:check`. `npm run pages:check` passed after GitHub Pages caught up. The regulated wastewater direct-answer and light-structured frontier text arms are now published and Pages-confirmed; the regulated wastewater full-OfOne frontier arm is not launched.
- 2026-05-21T04:56:10-06:00: Launched the Batch 01 `frontier_reasoning` regulated wastewater full-OfOne repeat-1 arm in a clean ChatGPT Deep Research conversation at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0ee4ad-8854-83e8-866e-f671c12880da. Launch proof: clean ChatGPT root/new-chat surface before submission, Deep Research enabled and composer showing `Pro`, prompt metadata visible for `2026-05-17-batch-01__case-regulated-wastewater-market-entry-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1`, generated plan title `Regulated wastewater market entry`, `Start` clicked, visible `Researching...`, and `Stop research` present. This is launch proof only; no completed report is visible, and the full-OfOne output is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T04:59:52-06:00: The active regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne repeat-1 run shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Regulated wastewater market entry`; step 1 is complete, step 2 is active, status text is `Focusing on regulatory evidence for wastewater market...`, count shows `6 searches` and `6 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so the full-OfOne output is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T05:02:50-06:00: The active regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne repeat-1 run shows material progress. Visible plan title remains `Regulated wastewater market entry`; step 1 is complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Troubleshooting search and container access...`, count advanced to `17 searches` and `17 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so the full-OfOne output is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T05:07:26-06:00: The active regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne repeat-1 run remains in progress. Visible plan title remains `Regulated wastewater market entry`; step 1 is complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Maximizing web calls and evaluating options...`, count remains `17 searches` and `17 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so the full-OfOne output is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T05:15:00-06:00: The active regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne repeat-1 run remains in progress. Visible plan title remains `Regulated wastewater market entry`; step 1 is complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Clarifying top-level schema requirements...`, count remains `17 searches` and `17 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so the full-OfOne output is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T05:32:08-06:00: The active regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne repeat-1 run resumed material progress before crossing into a stall state. Visible plan title remains `Regulated wastewater market entry`; step 1 is complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Defining JSON structure and frame types...`, count remains `17 searches` and `17 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so the full-OfOne output is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T05:37:50-06:00: The active regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne repeat-1 run shows further material progress. Visible plan title remains `Regulated wastewater market entry`; step 1 is complete, step 2 is active, status text changed to `Addressing potential issues and refining schema elements...`, count remains `17 searches` and `17 sources searched`, and `Stop research` remains present. No completed report is visible, so the full-OfOne output is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T05:45:37-06:00: The regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` full-OfOne repeat-1 arm completed in ChatGPT Deep Research with visible metadata `Research completed in 45m`, `5 citations`, `22 searches`, `21 May`, `5 sources`, report title `Benchmark Raw Output`, and run metadata `Status: completed`. Exported Markdown source `/Users/jamesbrady/Downloads/deep-research-report (42).md` was copied to `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/outputs/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-regulated-wastewater-market-entry-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1.md` with SHA-256 `047dbd2e832eea80067ef3865ab056158dc9bb5c67b391b809783afd89170a9e`. Artifact JSON, computed validator JSON, rendering, patch report, and local review were added. Computed local validation failed relation legality and relation-family checks, so the full-OfOne slot is completed/reviewed but excluded before aggregate scoring and is not aggregate-eligible. Publication and Pages parity are pending until commit/push.
- 2026-05-21T06:10:00-06:00: Prepared and executed the regulated wastewater Mode A controlled contract at `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/frontier-run-packets/2026-05-21-regulated-wastewater-frontier-full-r1-mode-a-contract.md`. Controlled rerun `2026-05-17-batch-01__case-regulated-wastewater-market-entry-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1__rerun1` produced raw output, artifact JSON, computed validator JSON, rendering, patch report, and local review. The computed validator passed with only the expected superiority-readiness warning. The execution matrix records rerun1 under `remedial_runs` as `replace_for_aggregate_only`; the original excluded wastewater run remains immutable. Publication and Pages parity are still pending until this batch is committed and pushed.
- 2026-05-21T06:16:00-06:00: Public commit `c9364a8` pushed the regulated wastewater controlled rerun1 package, matrix/manifest updates, public links, refreshed checker attestation, and frontier repair guards. Local verification passed `git diff --check`, `npm run schema:check`, `npm run validate`, `npm run review:check`, `npm run research:check`, `npm run benchmark`, `npm test`, `npm run frontier:protocol:check`, `npm run frontier:controlled:check`, direct validator/render/patch commands for the controlled artifact, and `npm run pages:check` after GitHub Pages caught up. The package is now published and Pages-confirmed.
- 2026-05-21T06:23:00-06:00: Prepared the next predeclared `frontier_reasoning` repeat-1 packet for `case-formal-proof-search-001` at `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/frontier-run-packets/2026-05-21-formal-proof-search-frontier-r1.md`. Status is `prepared_not_launched`; no formal proof-search frontier arm is launched, harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible without clean ChatGPT Deep Research launch proof and later harvest/review/publication evidence.
- 2026-05-21T06:30:21-06:00: Public commit `7de74a8` pushed the formal proof-search frontier repeat-1 packet and public references. Local verification passed `git diff --check`, `node --check scripts/ofone-pages-check.mjs`, `npm run research:check`, `npm run validate`, `npm run schema:check`, `npm run review:check`, `npm run frontier:protocol:check`, `npm run frontier:controlled:check`, `npm run benchmark`, and `npm test`. `npm run pages:check` initially saw a transient homepage hash mismatch while the formal packet already matched Pages; after retry, GitHub Pages parity passed. Status remains `prepared_not_launched`.
- 2026-05-21T06:45:50-06:00: Tool discovery for Chrome-extension/ChatGPT tab control did not expose a callable Chrome extension/plugin namespace in this thread. Under the current launch policy, Browser, Computer Use, coordinate clicking, AppleScript/JXA, and generic desktop automation are not fallback launch paths. The formal proof-search frontier packet is now `prepared_blocked_chrome_extension_unavailable`; no ChatGPT conversation was opened, no prompt was submitted, no Deep Research plan was generated, and no formal proof-search frontier slot is launched, harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T06:56:59-06:00: Hardened the Chrome-extension-first Deep Research policy at the skill/publication layer. The skill protocol now prefers Chrome-extension-managed isolated tabs for parallel Deep Research packets, public docs and the homepage link the research lifecycle checker, Pages parity checks include `scripts/ofone-research-check.mjs`, and the tooling contract asserted the then-current Chrome-blocker diagnostics. At that time, the formal proof-search frontier packet remained `prepared_blocked_chrome_extension_unavailable`.
- 2026-05-21T07:01:44-06:00: Added the Chrome-extension launch queue handoff at `research/chrome-extension-deep-research-contract.md` and `research/deep-research-launch-queue.json`, with schema `schemas/ofone.deep-research-launch.schema.json`, checker `scripts/ofone-deep-research-launch-check.mjs`, and package command `npm run deep-research:check`. This gives future callable Chrome extension control a deterministic isolated-tab queue for parallel Deep Research packets while preserving the current blocker: no ChatGPT conversation was opened, no prompt was submitted, and no formal frontier slot is launched, harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T07:14:00-06:00: Added Chrome-extension tab payload generation: `research/deep-research-extension-payloads.json`, `schemas/ofone.deep-research-extension-payloads.schema.json`, `scripts/ofone-deep-research-extension-payloads.mjs`, and package commands `npm run deep-research:payloads` / `npm run deep-research:payloads:write`. The payload file extracts the exact formal proof-search direct-answer prompt from the packet, records packet and prompt hashes, assigns an isolated tab lane, and preserves the current `wait_for_callable_chrome_extension_control` action because tool discovery still exposes no callable Chrome-extension namespace. No ChatGPT conversation was opened, no prompt was submitted, and no formal frontier slot is launched, harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T07:18:52-06:00: Added Chrome-extension report intake: `research/deep-research-extension-report.json`, `schemas/ofone.deep-research-extension-report.schema.json`, `scripts/ofone-deep-research-extension-report-check.mjs`, and package command `npm run deep-research:report`. At that time, the report bound to the current payload hash and recorded the formal proof-search direct-answer lane as `observed_blocked`; future launch, active, harvest, or rejection states required Chrome-extension proof fields and raw-output hash proof before any local state promotion.
- 2026-05-21T07:29:08-06:00: Wired the Chrome-extension queue/payload/report blocked-state binding into `scripts/ofone-research-check.mjs` and the tooling contract tests. This promoted the extension report from a specialist `deep-research:*` check into the broader research lifecycle gate, so any future launch/harvest promotion had to preserve queue, payload, and report consistency.
- 2026-05-21T07:41:10-06:00: Resolved Chrome extension/plugin launch control through the Codex Chrome browser-client extension backend via `mcp__node_repl__js` and launched the Batch 01 `frontier_reasoning` formal proof-search direct-answer repeat-1 arm in a clean ChatGPT Deep Research conversation at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0f0a85-c75c-83e8-b0d0-4c15a041cb7b. Launch proof: Deep Research enabled, composer model `Pro`, prior model selector visible with `Latest • 5.5` and `Pro • Extended`, generated plan title `Formal proof map`, visible Start countdown elapsed, active state `Summarizing sources and establishing testing methods...`, and stop-control evidence visible. No Browser plugin, Computer Use, coordinate clicking, AppleScript/JXA, generic desktop automation, or desktop-control fallback was used. This is active launch proof only; no completed report is visible, and the formal proof-search frontier slot is not harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T07:58:10-06:00: Chrome-extension observation reached the same formal proof-search conversation and found the internal Deep Research iframe mounted, but the iframe body returned empty text; the outer ChatGPT DOM exposed no Stop research control, no progress text, no Research completed metadata, and Copy response returned only the original prompt. `research/deep-research-extension-report.json` now records status `observation_blocked`. No harvest, relaunch, review, completion, or aggregate eligibility is allowed until a completed-report surface is visible through Chrome extension control.
- 2026-05-21T08:50:37-06:00: The formal proof-search `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer repeat-1 arm completed in ChatGPT Deep Research through the Chrome extension path. Visible metadata: `Research completed in 10m`, `8 citations`, `101 searches`, report title `Benchmark Raw Output`, and run metadata `Status: completed`. Exported Markdown source `/Users/jamesbrady/Downloads/deep-research-report (43).md` was copied to `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/outputs/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-formal-proof-search-001__direct_answer__frontier_reasoning__r1.md` with SHA-256 `16ee781550c471e01b92ae4f577a04de8d54a6be0ec27a6dab34d547dcbef784`. Local review was added at `benchmarks/reviews/2026-05-17-batch-01/2026-05-17-batch-01__case-formal-proof-search-001__direct_answer__frontier_reasoning__r1.md`; the slot passed pre-score compliance and is aggregate-eligible locally pending commit, push, and Pages confirmation. `research/deep-research-extension-report.json` records status `harvested`, and `research/deep-research-launch-queue.json` / `research/deep-research-extension-payloads.json` record status `reviewed`.
- 2026-05-21T09:12:00-06:00: The formal proof-search `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer repeat-1 arm is now committed in `29669c4`, pushed, and Pages-confirmed. Launched the clean isolated formal proof-search `frontier_reasoning` light-structured repeat-1 arm through Chrome extension control at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0f1fe5-3494-83e8-9f92-1a2b732c4958. Launch proof: clean ChatGPT root before submission, Deep Research enabled, composer model `Pro`, prior model selector visible with `Latest • 5.5` and `Pro • Extended`, prompt metadata visible for `2026-05-17-batch-01__case-formal-proof-search-001__light_structured__frontier_reasoning__r1`, generated plan/progress card title `Formal proof map`, active state `Looking for Quickcheck or Nitpick source...`, active progress bar, and stop-control evidence visible. No Browser plugin, Computer Use, coordinate clicking, AppleScript/JXA, generic desktop automation, or desktop-control fallback was used. This is active launch proof only; no completed report is visible, and the light-structured slot is not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T09:34:52-06:00: Re-verified Chrome extension availability through `mcp__node_repl__js`; `nodeRepl.requestMeta` exposed `chrome` and `iab` backends and `globalThis.browser` was present. The formal proof-search `frontier_reasoning` light-structured repeat-1 report is completed-visible at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0f1fe5-3494-83e8-9f92-1a2b732c4958. Visible metadata: `Research completed in 9m`, `6 citations`, `120 searches`, report title `Benchmark Raw Output`, run metadata `Status: completed`, and the correct run ID. Raw Markdown harvest remains blocked because the report body and download control are inside ChatGPT's cross-origin Deep Research sandbox iframe; top-level DOM/snapshot, Chrome `content.export`, Copy response, and virtual clipboard probes did not expose the report text. Status is `completed_report_visible`; no Browser plugin, Computer Use, coordinate clicking, AppleScript/JXA, generic desktop automation, or desktop-control fallback was used. The slot is not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T09:55:47-06:00: Rechecked the Chrome extension bridge before proceeding. `mcp__node_repl__js` is callable, `nodeRepl.requestMeta` exposes `chrome` and `iab` backends, `globalThis.browser` is present, and `browser.tabs.list()` returned 4 tabs. `research/deep-research-extension-report.json` now records that availability diagnostic and enumerates allowed Chrome-extension harvest probes for the completed-visible light-structured report: top-level DOM, iframe locator, direct sandbox tab, response menu, `content.export`, backend conversation request, and page-eval bridge probes. Raw Markdown remains unavailable; no fallback browser, desktop automation, coordinate clicking, AppleScript/JXA, or Computer Use path was used. The slot remains `completed_report_visible`, not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T10:06:03-06:00: Added additional Chrome-extension-only harvest probes for the completed-visible formal proof-search light-structured report. `tab.dev.logs` surfaced only sandbox adapter `MessageEvent` rejection logs and unrelated extension errors; `content.exportGsuite` rejected unsupported formats or reported the tab is not a Google Workspace document; `Copy response` left a sentinel clipboard value unchanged and the prior clipboard was restored. No raw Markdown was exposed, and no Browser plugin, Computer Use, coordinate clicking, AppleScript/JXA, generic desktop automation, or desktop-control fallback was used. The slot remains `completed_report_visible`, not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T10:20:04-06:00: Added the manual recovery gate for the completed-visible formal proof-search light-structured report: `research/deep-research-manual-recovery.json`, schema `schemas/ofone.deep-research-manual-recovery.schema.json`, and checker `scripts/ofone-deep-research-manual-recovery.mjs`. The gate is bound to the current queue/payload/report hashes, accepts only a native ChatGPT Markdown export that contains the exact light-structured run markers, forbids Browser/Computer Use/coordinate/OCR reconstruction paths, and confirms the raw output/review files are absent while status is `awaiting_operator_export`. This preserves the blocker; the slot remains not harvested, not reviewed, not complete, not aggregate-eligible, and not publishable.
- 2026-05-21T10:30:19-06:00: Rechecked the completed-visible formal proof-search light-structured report through the Chrome extension. The response More actions menu still exposed only timestamp, View sources, and Branch in new chat; the View sources panel opened but reported `No additional sources found` and exposed no report body, citations payload, download, export, Markdown, or raw report control. The extension report and manual recovery hash binding were refreshed without changing state. The slot remains `completed_report_visible`, not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T10:39:23-06:00: Rechecked additional first-party Chrome-extension surfaces for the completed-visible formal proof-search light-structured report. Page storage exposed no localStorage/sessionStorage matches and no IndexedDB or Cache Storage report payload; the Deep Research iframe body still read empty with no buttons or links; the current conversation options menu exposed Share, Start a group chat, View files in chat, Move to project, Pin chat, Archive, and Delete, but no export/download/Markdown control; `View files in chat` reported `No files referenced yet`. The extension report and manual recovery hash binding were refreshed without changing state. The slot remains `completed_report_visible`, not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T10:45:08-06:00: Rechecked additional Chrome-extension content/share paths for the completed-visible formal proof-search light-structured report. `browser.tabs.content` rejected text, HTML, and DOM snapshot extraction as unsupported by the Chrome backend; top-level and response Share modals exposed `Copy link` and LinkedIn controls but no native Markdown, download, export, report body, or raw report control. `Copy link` was not used. The extension report and manual recovery hash binding were refreshed without changing state. The slot remains `completed_report_visible`, not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T10:54:47-06:00: Rechecked through the full Chrome extension browser-client runtime. The extension is callable, the target ChatGPT tab is controllable, and the tab exposes Playwright, DOM CUA, dev-log, clipboard, and tab content APIs. Those APIs still expose only the ChatGPT shell, prompt metadata, an empty Deep Research iframe body, and response controls; no raw report Markdown is available. `browser.tabs.content` accepts only `html`, `text`, and `domSnapshot` content types, rejects Markdown-style content types at schema validation, and the Chrome backend rejects the supported `tabs_content` command. The response More actions menu still exposes timestamp, `View sources`, and `Branch in new chat`, with no native Markdown/download/export/report-body control. The extension report and manual recovery hash binding were refreshed without changing state. The slot remains `completed_report_visible`, not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T11:03:11-06:00: Found installed local skill drift: `/Users/jamesbrady/.codex/skills/ofone/SKILL.md` was still behind repo `SKILL.md`. Added `scripts/ofone-install-skill.mjs`, `npm run skill:install`, and `npm run skill:check`; updated README and tests; installed the live local skill so it now matches repo `SKILL.md` at `sha256:393945bb8cebbe8ba6b2ec91888d5947d6eb0f56823acbb26a7d2f2d3b72394a`. This preserves the Chrome-extension-first rule for future agents and does not promote the light-structured slot beyond `completed_report_visible`.
- 2026-05-21T11:13:21-06:00: Rechecked Chrome extension availability before any further workflow work; the Codex Chrome browser-client extension backend was callable and listed the existing formal proof-search light-structured ChatGPT report tab. Removed the OfOne skill's loose one-off manual-assist fallback and added an installer invariant requiring the stricter rule: if extension control is unavailable or clean tab isolation cannot be verified, troubleshoot extension availability before any benchmark, harvest, launch, or repo-promotion work. The installed local skill was refreshed from repo source. The light-structured slot remains `completed_report_visible`, not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T11:23:57-06:00: Rechecked Chrome extension availability before continuing. The extension bridge is callable with `browserId=extension`, and the existing formal proof-search light-structured `Benchmark Raw Output` tab is listed through `browser.tabs.list()` at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0f1fe5-3494-83e8-9f92-1a2b732c4958. The older `browser.tabs.query()` helper is not exposed by this bridge shape, so the skill/contract diagnostics now name `browser.tabs.list()` and warn not to misclassify a missing `query()` helper as extension failure. The manual recovery writer was hardened so any source-validation error blocks `--write`, even when required identity markers are present. The installed local skill was refreshed from repo source at `sha256:6e736da4728d51bb5802a2ec7f2c6f9adb7f8bfdc7613224a2af3366ddeaf488`. The light-structured slot remains `completed_report_visible`, not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T11:31:00-06:00: Added a native-export source scanner to the manual recovery checker (`npm run deep-research:manual-recovery:scan`) so future heartbeats can check the expected Downloads glob with marker validation instead of ad hoc shell searches. The current scan found 44 candidate `deep-research-report*.md` files but no valid native export for the formal proof-search light-structured run; newest candidate failures included missing exact run/case markers and already-harvested direct-answer arm markers. This preserves the blocker: the light-structured slot remains `completed_report_visible`, not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T11:51:15-06:00: Added first-class `blocked_runs` accounting to `benchmarks/runs/2026-05-17-batch-01/execution-matrix.json` for `2026-05-17-batch-01__case-formal-proof-search-001__light_structured__frontier_reasoning__r1`. The blocked record links the Chrome extension report and manual recovery gate, records `source_surface=chrome_extension_plugin`, keeps `aggregate_eligible=false`, and points to the expected raw output/review paths without creating them. The benchmark checker now validates blocked slots as predeclared, non-terminal, non-aggregate states backed by the extension/manual recovery reports. `completion.queued=37` plus `completion.blocked=1` plus 52 terminal slots preserves the 90-slot matrix. `npm run benchmark -- --json` passes. The slot remains `completed_report_visible`, not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T12:00:32-06:00: Rechecked Chrome extension availability and current harvest state before proceeding. The extension bridge is callable through `mcp__node_repl__js`; `globalThis.browser.browserId` is `extension`; `browser.tabs.list()` returns the target `Benchmark Raw Output` conversation; and `browser.tabs.get(tabId)` exposes Playwright, DOM CUA, clipboard, content, and dev-log helpers. A fresh `npm run deep-research:manual-recovery:scan` found 44 candidate native export files and still no marker-valid light-structured export. Added method-shape hardening to `SKILL.md`, `research/chrome-extension-deep-research-contract.md`, README, installer invariants, and tests so future agents use `browser.tabs.get(tabId)` for rich tab helpers, `browser.tabs.content({ urls, contentType })` with camelCase `contentType`, no-argument `tab.content.export()`, and string-form `tab.content.exportGsuite(format)`. The installed local skill was refreshed at `sha256:36b59bd3d668e247604f07c3207b364af632d78ae7d20a76024e1cf58bada124`. No Browser plugin, Computer Use, coordinate clicking, AppleScript/JXA, generic desktop automation, OCR, or screenshot reconstruction path was used. The light-structured slot remains `completed_report_visible`, not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T12:08:08-06:00: Rechecked the completed-visible formal proof-search light-structured report with the corrected Chrome bridge method shapes. Chrome extension control remains callable and reaches the target tab, but corrected `browser.tabs.content({ urls, contentType })` calls still fail on backend `tabs_content`, `tab.content.export()` fails on unsupported `tab_content_export`, and `tab.content.exportGsuite(format)` reports the ChatGPT tab is not a Google Workspace document. Added structured JSON details to manual recovery source-scan diagnostics so future automation can consume candidate count, newest candidate marker failures, and valid candidate paths from `--json` output without parsing prose. No valid native export exists yet; no Browser plugin, Computer Use, coordinate clicking, AppleScript/JXA, generic desktop automation, OCR, or screenshot reconstruction path was used. The light-structured slot remains `completed_report_visible`, not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable.
- 2026-05-21T12:17:44-06:00: Rechecked Chrome extension availability and the manual recovery source scan before moving the benchmark handoff forward. The extension remains callable and the light-structured target tab remains visible, but no marker-valid native export exists. Added mixed-state Chrome-extension queue support so `research/deep-research-launch-queue.json`, `research/deep-research-extension-payloads.json`, and `research/deep-research-extension-report.json` can carry the next formal proof-search `full_ofone` repeat-1 item as `prepared_not_launched` / `launch_ready` while the light-structured item remains completed-visible and blocked. The payload generator now supports the full prompt's four-backtick Markdown fence. No full-OfOne ChatGPT conversation has been opened; there is no launch proof, harvest, local review, completion, or aggregate eligibility for that item.
- 2026-05-21T12:33:26-06:00: Attempted the next formal proof-search full-OfOne launch through the Chrome extension plugin only. The extension was available (`browserId=extension`, `browser.tabs.new()`, `tab.goto()`, and `tab.playwright` locators worked), a clean ChatGPT conversation was created at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0f4f44-f800-83e8-851b-a71bbd2596d2, Deep research was selected, the model control showed `Pro`, and the exact payload prompt for `2026-05-17-batch-01__case-formal-proof-search-001__full_ofone__frontier_reasoning__r1` was submitted. The page briefly exposed `Stop answering`, then stabilized with only the submitted user prompt and no generated plan, Start/countdown action, active research state, or stop-control evidence. This is not valid launch proof. The item remains `prepared_not_launched` / report `launch_ready`; do not mark it launched, active, harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T12:48:24-06:00: Continued the no-start diagnosis through the Chrome extension plugin only. The extension bridge is available (`node_repl` exposes the `chrome` backend, `globalThis.browser.browserId=extension`, and `browser.tabs.list()` succeeds). The first no-start conversation at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0f4f44-f800-83e8-851b-a71bbd2596d2 still contains only the submitted user prompt and no generated plan, Start/countdown action, active research state, or stop-control evidence; its internal Deep Research iframe is mounted but has an empty body and no iframe buttons. A second clean isolated retry at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0f52da-bad8-83e8-9f09-91506f511e05 reproduced the same state with the exact hash-bound prompt and `Deep research` / `Pro` controls visible. `tab.dev.logs` repeatedly reported `Ignoring message from unknown source MessageEvent` from `connector_openai_deep_research.web-sandbox.oaiusercontent.com/assets/adapter-1qEBlSq4.js`. This is a reproduced Chrome-extension Deep Research handoff failure, not launch proof. The item remains `prepared_not_launched` / report `launch_ready`; do not mark it launched, active, harvested, reviewed, complete, or aggregate-eligible.
- 2026-05-21T12:58:05-06:00: Rechecked the Chrome extension path before any other workflow work. The extension is available through `mcp__node_repl__js`; `nodeRepl.requestMeta` exposes `chrome` and `iab` backends, `globalThis.browser.browserId=extension`, and `browser.tabs.list()` succeeds with four ChatGPT tabs. A diagnostic `Deep Research Smoke Test` conversation is visible at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0f5518-8494-83e8-809f-c0514a1da5ea. It shows only the submitted smoke prompt, Deep Research and Pro controls, the internal Deep Research iframe mounted as a shell, no generated plan, Start/countdown action, active research state, or stop-control evidence, and repeated `Ignoring message from unknown source MessageEvent` logs. This is a Deep Research handoff no-start diagnostic, not Chrome-extension unavailability and not benchmark evidence. The formal proof-search full-OfOne item remains `prepared_not_launched` / report `launch_ready`; no Browser plugin, Computer Use, coordinate clicking, AppleScript/JXA, generic desktop automation, OCR, or screenshot reconstruction path was used.

## Harvest Rule

Run 07 has been harvested, adjudicated, and integrated. The remedial `full_ofone` rerun plus all five `agentic_coding` repeat-1 slices, all five `agentic_coding` repeat-2 slices, and all five `agentic_coding` repeat-3 slices have been published and Pages-confirmed. All three `frontier_reasoning` strategic repeat-1 arms have completed and been harvested. The direct-answer and light-structured strategic frontier arms are aggregate-eligible; the original strategic full-OfOne frontier arm is completed/reviewed but excluded before aggregate scoring because computed semantic validation failed. The full-OfOne frontier harvest/exclusion state was published in commit `373198f`, and Pages checker coverage for the full evidence bundle was published in `2099f89`. Remedial frontier full-OfOne reruns 1-4 are preserved as failed remedial evidence outside aggregate scoring. Controlled Mode A rerun5 is now the current strategic replacement record under `remedial_runs` with `aggregate_policy=replace_for_aggregate_only`; it is validator-valid, locally reviewed, committed in `7068ea8`, pushed, and Pages-confirmed. The original excluded strategic run remains immutable. The regulated wastewater `frontier_reasoning` direct-answer and light-structured repeat-1 arms are harvested, locally reviewed, committed in `1ffcf96`, pushed, Pages-confirmed, and aggregate-eligible. The original regulated wastewater `full_ofone` frontier arm completed at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0ee4ad-8854-83e8-866e-f671c12880da and has raw/artifact/validator/rendering/patch/review evidence, but computed local validation failed relation legality and relation-family checks; it remains completed/reviewed, excluded, and immutable. Controlled Mode A wastewater rerun1 is validator-valid, locally reviewed, committed in `c9364a8`, pushed, Pages-confirmed, matrix-inserted as `replace_for_aggregate_only` replacement evidence, and not a new predeclared slot. The formal proof-search frontier repeat-1 direct-answer arm completed in ChatGPT Deep Research at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0f0a85-c75c-83e8-b0d0-4c15a041cb7b through the Chrome extension plugin; it is harvested, locally reviewed, aggregate-eligible, committed in `29669c4`, pushed, and Pages-confirmed. The formal proof-search frontier repeat-1 light-structured report is completed-visible at https://chatgpt.com/c/6a0f1fe5-3494-83e8-9f92-1a2b732c4958 through Chrome extension control with status `completed_report_visible`; raw Markdown harvest is blocked by the cross-origin Deep Research iframe, and `research/deep-research-manual-recovery.json` is only an `awaiting_operator_export` gate, so it is not harvested, reviewed, complete, aggregate-eligible, or publishable. Superiority claims remain blocked.